Related
The rebootedStar Trekseries introduce a ton of change to the well established science - fiction franchise . Suddenly , Iowa had vast , rocky canyons in the center of it and Starfleet built the Enterprise on Earth rather of in space where it made sense . It was a lot for fans to adjust to .
Obviously those were n’t the only alterations in the Modern " Kelvin timeline . " Thanks to the changes in history from the 2009 movie ’s villain Nero traveling back in fourth dimension , Kirk ’s father did n’t subsist as long as he should have .
We also desire you were n’t too attached to Vulcan because that went away , too . However , on a more basic horizontal surface , all of the major type get new actors to act as them , and we fuck off some new graphic symbol as well .
It ’s laborious enough let the casting right in any movie , but the creators of the reboot had an even gravid job than most . It was n’t enough just to get good actors– they had to get salutary histrion who could also recapture the spirit of mass some fans had been follow for over 40 year .
Things turn out mostly fine , gratuitous electron lens flare aside , but that does n’t intend that we were happy with all the choice .
That ’s not to say that these were bad performance , of necessity . Some were , but others were just bad or weird choices . Also , in the spirit of equal play , we ’re include some casting conclusion that were spot - on and accomplish everything they call for to .
Here are the10 Casting Decisions That Hurt Star Trek Movies ( And 10 That save Them ) .
Hurt: Chris Hemsworth
Nobody involved inStar Trekhad any idea that two years after their movie come out , Chris Hemsworth would join the MCU as Thor Odinson . However , he did .
Like all of Hemsworth ’s pre- and post - Marvel study , it ’s difficult not to see him as the darling ( but not strongest ) Avenger– even without the beard .
He does just ticket during his abbreviated appearance as James Kirk ’s doomed father , George . His inclusion here is n’t his break at all . However , we ’re still stuck intellection of him as the god of roar .
We have standardised bother watchingThe Cabin in the Woodsnow– and that came out afterThor .
We allow in that this is mostly our inability to compartmentalize worker ’ character and not anything that the makers ofStar Trekdid . However , it ’s still uncanny in retrospect .
Saved: Idris Elba
Krall , the adversary of 2016’sStar Trek : Beyond , is a one - dimensional baddie . He wants to blow thing up because of Space Madness and some flimsy , militaristic reasoning directly out of Michael Bay’sThe Rock .
sincerely , the only affair he has fail for him is that Idris Elba plays him .
Idris Elba has made a lump of his career out of making even mediocre movies room more palatable .
He did this forPrometheus , Pacific Rim , andThe Dark Tower . Even if you wish these movies , which is fine , you have to admit it was at least partially because of him .
Beyondis a fun metre , honestly , but that scoundrel needed some presence– and Elba saves him .
Hurt: Simon Pegg
Simon Pegg ’s performance as Chief Engineer Montgomery Scott is really honorable . Nobody ’s here to claim that . However , we have a mates consequence with it that are n’t his trouble .
The main one is that while he does a great chore and we enjoy him in the office , he does n’t quite “ feel ” correct . Original worker James Doohan cater the define version of the fiber , and it ’s a tough performance to retroflex .
Newcomers to the franchise do n’t have this issue , patently , and we kind of envy them .
Pegg does a great job , but the dispute between him and Doohan is big enough to be distracting . Also , it also does n’t help that we have the same Hemsworth problem in that we associate Pegg more with his work in director Edgar Wright ’s moving-picture show and theMission : Impossibleseries .
Saved: Shohreh Aghdashloo
fan of rescued sci - fi seriesThe Expansewere probably exhilarate to hear the typical voice of actress Shohreh Aghdashloo in the trailers forBeyond .
Even masses who have never seen a single instalment still had to be jolly happy because we could mind to that charwoman read cooky recipe , and it would whole enthrall us .
Aghdashloo flirt Commodore Paris . She ’s Captain Kirk ’s direct superior after Christopher Pike ’s death inInto duskiness , and he occur to her with his doubt about continuing his command .
She ’s only in a couple scenes , but they ’re great because every time she say anything , it go incredible .
The filmmakers made the arrant call have Aghdashloo ’s lines form the voiceover for the trailer . It made us desire to buy ticket immediately .
Hurt: Noel Clarke
Noel Clarke has a flyspeck role in the punctuation - freeStar Trek Into Darkness . He play a Federation police officer who Khan blackmails into destroy an intelligence chemical compound with a turkey that looks like a ring and activates in water .
Of all the things in the movie that make no sense , this make the least sense .
Clarke is another actor whose appearance endure from our premature association . He appear for a few seasons onDoctor Whoas Mickey Smith . Unfortunately , that ’s how we ’re always going to think of him .
That ’s nothing against his work in either series .
However , for the abbreviated time he ’s on filmdom , we just kept thinking , “ That ’s Mickey . What ’s wrong with Mickey ? ”
This is far from our biggest problem with this entry , but it ’s another chunk we can chip out of it .
Saved: Sofia Boutella
Like Idris Elba , Sofia Boutella raise almost every movie she ’s in , even if it ’s not that great to begin with . However , this is n’t true of the bungled Universal reboot ofThe Mummy , which is beyond even her powers .
Beyond is decent even without her , but she enhances it , regardless .
Her grapheme , Jayla , provide some of the humour and sport that the series mischievously require after the workout in rigor thatInto Darknesswas .
Besides that , Boutella gets to show off her awe-inspiring scrap and acrobatic skills later on . Unlike her function inKingsman : The Secret Service , the exceptional effects team lets her keep her real , humanoid leg .
Of all the new lineament we ’ve contact in the reboots , we ’re most hoping to see Jayla again in sequel .
Hurt: Eric Bana
As a serial , Star Trekhas a minute of a villain problem . This is true in both the original movies and the Kelvin 1 .
Other thanThe Wrath of Khan , The Undiscovered Country , andFirst Contact , the enfranchisement is full of deadening , one - note baddie who do n’t stick with the interview much longer than the moving picture lasts .
A undecomposed performance , however , can make up for shortcomings in a character or a handwriting .
unluckily , the 2009 movir does n’t have that . Its adversary , Nero , is unforced to snuffle out one million million of life to avenge his syndicate . We get why that vocalise good on paper , but it becomes progressively farfetched while we determine it .
Sadly , the bad Bruce Banner ca n’t make up for these issues . He just scowl and yells a lot .
Saved: Greg Grunberg
Director J.J. Abrams make out to put Greg Grunberg in his labor . He ’s almost a human Easter egg most of the prison term . In fact , he cater the voice - over for Kirk ’s stepfather in the 2009 motion picture .
However , his beefier performance inBeyond(which Abrams did n’t direct ) was an even with child treat for rooter of the doer , who somehow made a movie calledBig Ass Spidercharming .
He plays Commander Finnegan , the first military officer of the blank space station Yorktown , which becomes the mark of Krall near the end of the movie .
Finnegan relays the parliamentary procedure that gets The Beastie Boys ’ “ Sabotage ” blast out into space to destruct the exotic fleet point flat for them . That ’s several steps up from yelling at young James Kirk not to slip his railway car .
Hurt: Tyler Perry
Writer / director / actor Tyler Perry come along inStar Trekas Starfleet Academy commandant Admiral Richard Barnett , and it is deflect .
Even beyond this , it did n’t really feel like Perry need to be there .
He really just desire to ferment with J.J. Abrams , and we ’re happy that play out for him . However , when he took the chore , Perry was apparentlynot a sports fan of the serial .
“ I ’m telling you it was J.J Abrams , ” Perry said . “ He talked me into it and it ’s a near thing I did n’t see the lastStar Trekmovie or I would have said no , ” he allege .
While we harbor standardised feeling towardNemesis , the final cinematic outing for theNext Generationcrew , that ’s a spot abrasive .
Saved: Peter Weller
Into Darknessmakes a plenty of missteps in its plot , character , and adherence to the franchise , but we ’re beaming Abrams and the producer at least bothered to lend Peter Weller in as Admiral Marcus .
TheRobocopactor is always nice to see in anything . The cat managed to sellThe Adventures of Buckaroo Bonzai Across the eighth Dimension , for one matter , and that picture show is just awful nonsense from begin to end .
Into Darkness is so mismatched that we appreciate induce him to anchor the whole thing , even if only tenuously .
We ca n’t honestly say that he saves the movie– that would be pushing it– but at least we could depend on him to make his scenes mostly watchable .
