Related
The creators of theHarry Pottermovies had a much harder job than the masses who are makingGame of Thrones . They were grow the pic while J. K. Rowling was still releasing the books at a decent stride , so they were being confronted with repugnance as they were making the movie . Meanwhile , theGame of Thronespeople can do moderately much whatever they require , as we probably wo n’t be seeing a newA Song of Iceand Firenovel until after the show stop .
There were some case where theHarry Pottermovies made incredibly dumb mistakes , which has caused some devotee to question whether or not the creators were concerned in the report making common sense . Some fans believe that they were just trying to pump the movies out before Daniel Radcliffe pose too onetime to convincingly recreate Harry Potter .
We are here today to look at the secret plan holes that are sole to theHarry Pottermovies– from the death of Quirrell that did n’t leave much of an impression to the questionable fate of one of the most significant character in the series .
Here are the15 Plot Holes In The Harry Potter Movies !
Why Wasn’t Harry Expelled At The Start Of Prisoner Of Azkaban?
One of the way in which the existence of magic is keep veil is through rigid enforcement of laws relating to underage wizards . All necromancer vernal than seventeen have a Trace appealingness placed on them , which informs the Ministry whenever magic is used in the vicinity of the child . The minor wiz usually get a couple of warnings , look on the severeness of the offense .
The Divine ofPrisoner of Azkabanseem to have all forgotten about this formula , as Harry is seen repeatedly using the Lumos Maxima magical spell while still at Privet Drive . This repugnance is made even more apparent by the fact that Harry get in fuss for blow up Marge Dursley not long after the moving-picture show starts .
It also becomes a cock-a-hoop plenty inOrder of the Phoenix , when the fact that Harry apply a Patronus to track off some Dementors lands him in court . It would have saved everyone a lot of trouble if Harry had just bought a lamp .
The Curse On Voldemort’s Name
One scenery that was deleted contains entropy about one of the most of import changes to the world ofHarry Potterthat happened after Voldemort ’s hike to magnate . The Godhead of the movie decide to take out the explanation behind the Taboo curse that had been placed on Voldemort ’s name .
When Voldemort takes over the Ministry , he invokes a curse upon his name that uncover the locating of anyone who speaks it out loud . This is relevant because there are several scene where the Death Eaters get hold Harry because someone in the vicinity spoke Voldemort ’s name , such as when Xenophilius Lovegood verbalise the name in decree to bring the Death Eaters to his home .
This is also how the Death Eaters trail Harry when he is camping , which is how they capture him and take him to Malfoy Manor . Without the account as to the true nature of the Taboo , it makes it seem like the Death Eaters have incredibly good timing and tracking skills .
Why Does Snape Remember Lily’s Last Words To Harry When He Wasn’t There?
We never receive an explanation for how the Pensieve run in theHarry Potteruniverse . It allows the user to relive their own memories or the computer memory of others . When you actually live over the memory , you get to see everything that happened around the person , rather than just experiencing things through their eyes .
It seems that the movie version of the Pensieve has a rewind / tight - forward command , as Snape ’s memory inDeathly Hallows : Part 2contain moments that he should n’t have seen . When Harry employ the Pensieve to view Snape ’s memories , he witnesses the events that happened on the night his parent ’s died . Harry hear his female parent ’s last words to him and see Voldemort killing her .
How did Snape number to possess these computer memory ? He did n’t appear at Godric ’s Hollow until after Voldemort ’s onset had take place , which intend that he would have no agency of knowing exactly what materialise .
Lily’s Eyes Kept Changing Color
It seems that Snape ’s retentivity might not be true . He might be the Tyler Durden of theHarry Potterworld , as his Pensieve memories have all kinds of inconsistencies . This is especially straight when it comes to Lily Evans , as Snape ca n’t even keep the color of her eye uncoiled .
Throughout theHarry Potterseries , Harry is always running into associates of his parent who lay claim that he look just like his father , except for his eyes , which take care like his female parent ’s . In the Quran , Harry and his female parent both had green eyes . Daniel Radcliffe has blue eyes , so the makers of the flick hired a profane - eyed actress to portray his female parent .
However , it seems that the producers stopped care about continuity during the ending ofDeathly Hallows : Part 2 . In Snape ’s storage , the untested version of Lily has brownish center . This come shortly after the picture where Snape secern Harry that he has his mother ’s centre .
Harry Should Have Seen The Thestrals At The End Of The First Movie
InHarry Potter and the guild of the Phoenix , it is disclose that there are fauna called Thestrals that pull the baby buggy which take students from Hogsmeade station to Hogwarts . Only someone who has see dying at first hand can see them . Harry does n’t see them until the beginning ofOrder of the Phoenix , due to the fact that he go steady Cedric Diggory ’s murder the year before .
These same event happen in theHarry Pottermovies . The job is that Harry had find the expiry of Professor Quirrell during the climactic fight of the first movie . It was actually Harry who kill him with a death spot that was powered by the spell his female parent imparted onto him . He go out before he visualize Quirrell die in the books .
This plot hole does have a lawful account . The movie version ofHarry Potterand the Philosopher ’s Stonewas unfreeze before the book edition ofHarry Potter and the Order of the Phoenixwas released . As such , the creators of the movie never even knew that Thestrals existed . The later movies just never bothered to address the inconsistency .
They Never Explained The Meaning Behind The Marauder’s Names
By far the biggest omission from theHarry Pottermovies ( at least harmonise to the fan ) is the backstory concerning the Marauders inPrisoner of Azkaban . The write up of James Potter , Sirius Black , Peter Pettigrew , and Remus Lupin ’s time in Hogwarts is one of the most popular vista of the series .
However , the details of this backstory were almost completely removed from the moving picture . You ca n’t really charge the music director , as he require time to admit the vitally important stereotypical shrunken utter head and tree diagram fight sequence .
The removal of the Marauder ’s backstory would n’t be so much of an consequence if Harry did n’t keep referring to it in tardy movies . He refers to both Sirius Black and Peter Pettigrew as Padfoot and Wormtail without any explanation for what these footing mean . It might make sense to the people who have interpret theHarry Potterbooks , but those who have only seen the movies will be leave out in the cold as to the truthful signification of the figure .
How Did The Death Eaters Destroy The Millennium Bridge Before It Had Even Been Built?
At the scratch line ofHarry Potter and the Half - Blood Prince , the servants of Lord Voldemort have begin acting publically . They openly attack necromancer and muggles likewise , which stimulate the Prime Minister of England to take notice of the strange born disasters and ruinous accident that seem to be happening across the body politic .
One of the major incident triggered by the Death Eaters inHalf - Blood Princeinvolves the death of the Millennium Bridge in London . This roleplay as a replacement for a alike scene in the Christian Bible where the Brockdale Bridge break down . There is no such place as the Brockdale Bridge in London , so a real structure was choose to substitute it in the movies .
The job with using the Millennium Bridge is that it had n’t even been build up yet . TheHarry Pottermovies use the same timeline as the books . We bang this because James and Lily ’s gravestone uses the same death date as the one bring home the bacon in the books .
This mean that theHalf - Blood Princemovie takes stead in 1996 . building on the Millennium Bridge did n’t start until 1998 and it was n’t undecided to the world until the year 2000 .
The Magic Mirror Retcon
J. K. Rowling had n’t plan out all of the effect of theHarry Potterseries in advance . She only had a few plot point worked out beforehand . One of these demand Kreacher , which is why she stop the producers of the movies from leaving him out of the write up .
One view of the books that did end up becoming important later on on was the magic mirror that Sirius gave to Harry , which would tolerate the two of them to pass with each other . Harry used the mirror in the final Koran in edict to ( by chance ) contact Abeforth , who sent Dobby to save Harry and his friends from Malfoy Manor .
The mirror had been left out of the picture show adjustment ofOrder of the Phoenix . This meant that the producers of the plastic film just had to retcon in that Sirius had yield Harry a witching mirror at some gunpoint in the past tense . The fact that Harry never tried to practice it to contact Sirius ( especially when he needed to near the end ofOrder of the Phoenix ) is never deal .
The Reveal Of Harry’s Lie To The Dursleys
The firstHarry Potterbook and film end with Harry ascertain Hagrid that his aunt and uncle will start to behave themselves now , as they are unaware that he can not practice thaumaturgy outside of Hogwarts .
This actually backfires on Harry in the books , as the Dursleys lock up all of his magical equipment , which prevents him from contacting his friend . They discover the truth about Harry not being able-bodied to use magic after the Ministry sends a admonition letter to his house , due to Dobby do a cake fly around .
The alphabetic character never arrives in the movie version ofChamber of Secrets , intend that the Dursleys lock Harry up while he still has all of his witching equipment . In the book , Fred and George need pick locks in ordering to gain all of Harry ’s sorcerous gear .
If Harry still has his baton , then why does n’t he use it to run from Privet Drive ? Why are the Dursleys still so nerveless with ill-use a son who can make them all maturate tails like pigs ?
How Did Harry Know Remus & Tonks Had A Son?
Remus Lupin has a much large role in the Word than he does in the movies . There is a polar shot where he travels to Grimmauld Place and offers his services to Harry .
His supporter is refused , as Harry is aware that Lupin married Tonks and the two of them now have an infant son . Lupin believes that it would be better if he had no part in his son ’s life history , due to his status as a werewolf . However , Harry is able to win over Lupin to leave and recall to his family .
InDeathly Hallows : Part 2,Harry employ the Ressurection Stone to see the ghosts of his family and friends one last time before he faces Voldemort . He sees the ghost of Lupin and talk about how he never got a chance to see his Word .
So how did Harry have it away Lupin had a Logos ? The narrative of Remus and Tonks was almost totally off from the movies . Tonks was about to tell everyone before they left Privet Drive , but she was interrupted . Additionally , Harry never gets a hazard to get a line about the child ’s existence because he spends the last two movies on the outpouring .
