Related
When Marvel as a company was scramble in the ' 90s , it signed away the movie right wing to some of its biggest properties to make some extra hard cash . Those properties includedSpider - Man , theFantastic Four , theIncredible Hulk , and theX - Men , all of which finally made their way to the big screen door .
When Marvel began to bound back and was finally acquired by Disney , it wanted to commence making its own picture . The only problem was that the studio could n’t make movie found on the character and serial publication they already give up . And even as Marvel has slowly been able to work out deals to bring Spider - Man and Hulk back into their fold , Fox still has the sole movie rights for both the Fantastic Four and the 10 - Men .
grant the other characters that have joined the MCU after being with other studios , a pot of Marvel fans have been hoping that the Adam - Men can at last " come home " to Marvel and take their rightful topographic point within the MCU . However , we would argue that it would n’t be in the skillful interest of the ten - Men as a cinematic property to merge with the MCU .
This list is n’t out to take the 10 - Men flick aresuperiorto the MCU – we already did that– but instead , simply give reasons as to why it ’s better that the two cinematic cosmos persist separate .
Here are15 Reasons Why X - Men Is Better Off NOT In The MCU .
They can be more violent & mature
One of the things that the Disney buyout helped to cement for the MCU is that the movies would all be relatively fellowship - favorable . To be clear , there is perfectly nothing incorrect with risible book film being child - friendly , as comic record have traditionally been an all - ages medium that , for many years , were rather specifically aimed at tike and younger teens . It ’s also prissy for grownup who grew up readingIron ManandCaptain Americacomics to have picture they can now enjoy with their kid .
All that said , a plenty of comic booksareaimed at adult and have content that is too pictorial and mature to be contained within a PG-13 rating . Fortunately , theX - Menmovies currently have the choice to go to the full R - blackleg , and it ’s unlikely thatDeadpoolwould be allowed to cast off F - bombs and Wolverine would be grant to decapitate people if they were bought of the MCU .
The mature charge the X - Men pic have taken has n’t just been for cheap quiver either , as the passing dark and violentLoganhas been one of the most critically - hail comic book film of all time and has even garnered some Best Picture Oscar bombilation .
Quicksilver
Fox and Marvel butted heads over which should be able to use the sib team ofScarlet WitchandQuicksilver . Fox lobbied that they are the offspring of Magneto and are relegate as mutants– anX - Men - specific concept– and Marvel debate that they have traditionally been more associated with the Avengers . in the end , the two sides agreed to share– and before long enough , double Quicksilvers appeared in picture form .
The 10 - Men movies made great purpose of the character , withAmerican Horror Story ’s Evan Peters depict his brashness flawlessly– not to observe that incredible deadening - mo jailbreak scene inDays of Future Past . The MCU give him a big role inAge of Ultron , and then … kill him . In fact , he is one of the only MCU characters to actually die so far , and Kevin Feige says there is no plan to revive him . Besides that , Aaron Taylor Johnson ’s version just but was n’t as proficient .
So , what that in mind , X - Men joining the MCU would imply having to get rid of the better– and only currently living– cinematic variant of Quicksilver . And no X - Man should have to die just so the squad can join the MCU .
The franchise would have to be rebooted
Beginning with the 2000X - Menmovie and keep on at least through next year’sDark PhoenixandDeadpool 2 , theX - Menmovies have all been part of a single overall canyon . That is nearly two decades of a individual overarching cinematic universe , impressive by any standard but especially in the world of comic leger movies– by comparing , Spider - Man is already on histhirdincarnation in that same span of time .
There is picayune doubt that Marvel Studios would entirely reboot the entireX - Mencinematic universe if the mutant team unite the MCU . For a serial that has worked so hard to stay logical , bring back most of the same actors for days and years , and even find out a creative way to do a subdued reboot but still tie back into in the same existing continuity , it would be a shame for that to all go out and be undone basically just on rule .
TheX - Menfranchise is up to ten installments with two more already in yield – an achievement rival only by the MCU itself– and that staggering campaign should keep become for as long as it ’s still working , critically and commercially .
MCU would devalue Logan
If you ’re read this inclination than you ’ve likely already seenLogan , but we ’ll still trample a bit lightly and just say that the " modern - twenty-four hour period " versions of both Wolverine and Charles Xavier bid their leave to theX - military personnel franchise in that moving picture . It was a potent remainder for both characters , and brought them the type of unequivocal , creatively satisfying closure seldom afforded to comic volume movie heroes . More significantly , actors Hugh Jackman and Patrick Stewart brought their metre play the epic type to a closing curtain after an amazing 17 - twelvemonth streak .
Fortunately , the way theX - Menfranchise has refocused itself towards the past has allowed for the untested interpretation of Charles Xavier , at least , to believably live on through another actor . affair will be tougher with Jackman , as he has play Logan / Wolverine in all notable show of the part .
Still , both actors convey their characters full forget me drug and give them powerful endings that deserve some meter to adhere . We all know that the very bit the X - Men join the MCU , we ’d immediately see present - day Wolverine and Professor X proceeds , recast– and when that happen , the gravity of the event ofLoganwill discontinue to mean anything .
Time travel
Other than thefirstCaptain Americamovie , the MCU films mostly take place in the " nowadays " of the moving-picture show ' overall timeline . Once the introductory timeline was install , the majority of MCU movies have continually move fore chronologically , with each one occupy seat in the purchase order that the films are released .
WithX - Men : First Class , the X - Men serial rewound thing back to the sixties , when the mutant squad first came together . Rather than being a one - off flashback film or a complete reboot , the next follow - up picture show bright serve as both a continuation toFirst Classand a sequel toX - human beings : The Last Stand , bringing the two ostensibly separateX - Mentimelines together and prove that theX - Menmovies were still part of one single canon . X - Men : Apocalypsethen proceed on from there . ThenLoganwas released a year later , plant at some compass point in a future tense 12 year from now .
Having the freedom to leap out all around in theX - Menmovie timeline has meant a good deal of creative freedom that the MCU does n’t have in its ever - advancing borderland . To misplace that would changeX - Menfor the worse .
The X-Men and the MCU use the same actors
The bigger the MCU mold gets , the fewer the useable actors to play parts in it . That ’s not to say that the earth is going to lead out of actors anytime before long , but there is a certain permanence to someone guide a part in the MCU that robs them of the chance to play another mirthful account book character .
Unless they move over to theX - Menseries , that is . Because theX - Menseries and the MCU are separate , an thespian like Josh Brolin can make for bothCableand Thanos– and so far , he seems like a dandy choice forbothcharacters . Brolin should n’t have had to take one or the other to play , nor should Chris Evans have lost the chance to make for Steve Rogers just because he was already Johnny Storm .
As long as theX - Menseries and the MCU do n’t come together , actors will have the hazard to fiddle multiple parts in comical book movies– which is a win both for the actors themselves , and the fans who deserve to see the substantially possible actor for a role despite who they ’ve already trifle .
More space for X-Men characters
Comic book movies as a whole tend to struggle with how to have heavy teams of characters properly represented in movies without feeling too crowded . Certainly , both theX - Menseries and the MCU have had problem with this , from the infamously overstuffedX - Men : The Last Standto any Avenger that is n’t Iron Man , Cap , Thor , Hulk , or Black Widow mostly being relegated to the desktop of most MCU movies .
TheX - Menmovies are also just as guilty as the MCU of continually wreak stories back around to a core handful of case , but they also do a better line of letting secondary characters gleam a snatch more and letting a bigger variety of characters take turns in the spotlight .
There have been far more XTC - man represented in pic thanAvengerscharacters , even though both have a hurl of dozens to run from . Joining the already - crowded MCU would likely have in mind that most of those secondaryX - Mencharacters would get phased out , and we ’d only have the four or five most pop tenner - man having any substantial presence .
X-Men would play second fiddle to Avengers
Not only would many of the more nicheX - Mencharacters simply disappear from motion picture screens if the squad joined the MCU , but the X - Men as a whole wo n’t be the stars of the show anytime soon . While it makes consummate gumption that the MCU was built around the Avengers up to this point , the fact stay that things have already been set in motion for them to continue being at the center of everything in the MCU for the foreseeable futurity .
If the hug drug - Men were to get together the MCU in the next few years , they ’d have to be pressure into the existing chain of events– much in the way Spider - Man was– and would n’t be as prominent as they merit to be .
Once the " Avengers phase " of the MCU is complete , maybe the X - Men could take over and become the glue that obtain the MCU together– but that ’s a large " what if " and a lot of thinking twelvemonth and year into the future . We ’ll scotch that bridgework when we get to it , but for now , the X - valet de chambre would definitely have to settle for being the B - team of the MCU and they do n’t merit that .
Separate, self-contained stories for the average viewer
While it has taken some roundabout way , the MCU has largely been focused on a single overarching plot . As it has build , it has become more and more more unmanageable to jump on board without going back and watching at least some of the movies that came before it .
It ’s not only daunting for the occasional moviegoer , but now has begun to wear on even the more rabid fans as MCU motion-picture show start to experience more like 2 - hour episodes in a decade - long television show than a serial of picture . It ’s hard to maintain that much excitement about a story that takesthatlong to contact its true climax .
By contrast , theX - Menmovies are largely self - check . While they ’ve generally been divided up into individual trilogies , just about every film can be enjoy on its own so long as the viewer brings at least a passing cognition of the characters . And induce things severalise into trilogies – actualtrilogies , unlike MCU ones– means more focused ( and more comic - related ) story that have actual beginnings , centre , andendings , and are n’t just always building to some major case that always feels years away .
Scrappier alternative to MCU
Even fan of the 10 - Menmovies have to admit that there are time when the flick just do n’t quite measure up to the MCU , or other big - budget Hollywood blockbuster . While there is no shortage of expensive - look setpieces and effects in the X - Men films and they sure as shooting are no slouch in that section , they definitely miss the polish of most MCU movies . But that ’s not a spoiled matter .
comical account book are n’t immaculate . Every frame of every varlet is n’t some flawless piece of fine art , and some artist are better than others . peculiarly during the X - Men ’s ' XC heyday , a variety of artist pull the squad ’s comics with wildly diverge result . That ’s part of the charm of comical playscript ; being drawn by human hands and being inherently rough - around - the - edges as a result .
When an gist in anX - Menmovie look a little off , or someone ’s outfit or hair style does n’t seem quite right , or a minute of playing either fall flavorless or goes way too over the top , it just adds to that ramshackle charm and its fidelity to the look of the source material .
