Related
Black Widowis an interesting case . A undercover agent rail by the KGB who went on to join Earth ’s Mightiest Heroes , the Avengers , her cartoon strip publishing history find her bounce back and forward between grinder and villain , femme fatale and relatable protagonist .
In the Marvel Cinematic Universe , act by Scarlett Johansson , she impart a grade of ruthlessness and professionalism to the Avengers ( not to mention a distaff comportment to a superhero squad dominated by men ) , and has become an indispensable part of the superhero landscape .
Just because she ’s interesting does n’t mean there are n’t parting of the Black Widow ’s personality and narration that make no sense . Over the many years since her comics unveiling ( plus her multiple appearance in blockbuster MCU moving-picture show ) , she ’s had all kind of opportunities for trumpery .
This list is going to discuss those noticeable plot hole , unexpected growing , and puzzling elements of her backstory that , upon reflexion , just do n’t have any rhyme or grounds . These can range from her history in the comics to her adjustment to the silver screen , from developmental cognitive operation at Marvel to theater director hinting at plot point that never come to be .
These are20 thing That Make No Sense About Black Widow .
She destroyed Hawkeye’s family
Hawkeye and Black Widow have a farsighted , painful history in the strip that seems to mostly orbit around Widow lead astray ol' Clint Barton . As show above , this was their dynamic from too soon on in the funnies , but things took a gruesome go in the more modern Ultimates plot line , which base an alternate universe Widow give away their friendship in the worst elbow room possible .
In this alternate timeline ( Earth-1610 , to be precise ) , both Widow and Hawkeye get promoted to the Ultimates , an all - lead SHIELD team . But it cursorily become out to have been infiltrated by a traitor– who could it be ?
Spoilers : It was Black Widow all along ! Black Widow from the Ultimates existence is a much more ruthless , manipulative , and violent edition , and this manifest in the most painful style possible for Clint : she leads a blackened ops team that finish his intact kinsfolk . His married woman Laura and his three offspring all perish in the incident , and Romanova even taunts her former teammate over it .
While this all may make sensory faculty in that substitute universe , fan of the MCU would only find cognitive dissonance read this news report .
It ’s just too weird to see arguably the stuffy of all the Avengers engaged in such a grisly conflict with each other . Hawkeye gets his revenge , but reader were still get out lost .
She was the most hated Avenger on Twitter
Companies have all kinds of ways to get across public opinion these days , and that definitely extend to social media networks like Twitter . In a study of Twitter ’s reaction to the MCU , investigator foundthat the most - disliked Avenger was none other than Natasha Romanoff .
The report was able to discern positive sentiments and negative opinion , and rule that about 3.5 % of tweet about the lineament were negative . The hate should n’t really storm anyone pay online fandoms ' story with female character , but at least there is still good tidings for Black Widow .
While she just scantily thump out Hawkeye ( by about 0.1 % ) for the title of most - disliked , she did n’t earn the title of least - like . See , the study also measured what percent of tweets were confident , and Black Widow scored high in that department than Thor , Nick Fury , and the Hulk . So Black Widow does have her share of rooter , which makes sense– she ’s a fun graphic symbol , and a good counterweight to the gaggle of prominent snowy man that mostly makes up Earth ’s Mightiest Heroes .
We suppose we should n’t really be surprised that a female character with an badly - advised love story plotline became the most detest Avenger on the net , but the hatred still does n’t make good sense .
She fell for Bruce Banner
You knew this one was coming . The Marvel Cinematic Universe is not on the nose be intimate for creating engaging canonical love stories , but this relationship still ranks at the bottom of the barrel .
Fans were perplexed when , seemingly out of nowhere , Natasha Romanoff foretell to Bruce Banner that she wanted him .
Black Widow has never really had one true romantic interest , even in the comedian , but this whole affair felt like author - managing director Joss Whedon grasping at chemistry that just was n’t really there . Mark Ruffalo reportedly endorsed the coupling betimes on , but he was just about the only one , as even the grapheme within the picture show retrieve the topic uncomfortable .
The relationship does n’t really go anywhere ( other than awkwardness ) , but the thing that create no good sense is why it was started in the first place .
Natasha suddenly has feel for the cat who almost fatally spite her ? Despite no anterior romance or any real flirting ? It just does n’t work .
Her name
By now , just about everyone in the world screw the Black Widow ’s substantial name in the MCU . She goes by Natasha Romanoff ( when she is n’t using an assumed name for a military mission ) or " Nat " to those who have a go at it her very well . Yet in the comics , her name is slightly yet noticeably different .
In the mirthful books , she is called Natalia Alianovna Romanova . She may still be a Nat in the comics ( and she has also gone by her MCU name there , as well ) , but it ’s definitely not the same . Here ’s the really puzzling part : her MCU surname is technically a mistranslation .
Russian is a complicated language , and it involves the gendering of nouns . Unlike several other common language , however , this practice in reality pass to surname . Male Russian surname have dissimilar postfix than female Russian surnames , and Romanoff correlates to the male version of the name , not the female .
The comics interpretation , Romanova , would be the right rendering of the name for a woman , and the one Black Widow would undoubtedly habituate , being Russian herself .
We do n’t eff why the MCU stuck with the ( slightly ) incorrect version of the last name– perhaps they thought " Natasha Romanoff " would be easy for American audiences to digest than " Natalia Romanova . "
Her cure for mind control
Black Widow ’s fist can overpower the effect of an Infinity Stone - who would have guessed ?
Early on inMarvel ’s Avengers , adversary Loki utilize a hefty scepter ( given to him by Thanos ) to control the mind of Erik Selvig and Hawkeye . Hawkeye turn out to be a major thorn in the side of the Avengers , stimulate a pitched battle on SHIELD ’s helicarrier . During this sequence , Black Widow and Hawkeye get into a fist battle , and Widow proves to be too much for the mind - controlled Sagittarius .
She have it off Hawkeye ’s head against a alloy railing , and that bring around the wizard mind control . easygoing .
It was only later revealed that Loki ’s scepter was , in fact , a container for the Mind Stone , one of the unimaginably powerful Infinity Stones . This get it twice implausible that Black Widow was able to combat the effects of Loki ’s mind control by doing nothing but punch . She later does the same to Selvig , and it ’s pretty percipient that the whole " getting hit in the head cure mind dominance " thing was a plot of land gimmick create to keep the story move , no matter how nonsensical it may be .
For now , we just have to take the fact that the magic of one of the most powerful artifacts in the Marvel universe was loosen by a normal human ’s punches .
Her mission in Iron Man 2
The Black Widow is one of SHIELD ’s top operatives . She ’s a unpitying assassin , an expert operator , and one of the ripe there is at sniffing out mystery . So when you think about it , it does n’t make a lot of mother wit that she ’s devote a mission where her whole role is to act as the part of Tony Stark ’s repository .
Nick Fury never really start in - depth when explain why he assigned the Widow to dwarf Stark , because she ’s basically only there to keep an centre on Iron Man and evaluate whether he ’s a practiced scene for the Avengers enterprise . She flunks Tony but passes Iron Man , and then Ivan Vanko starts mess up poppycock up so she goes and helps out .
sure enough , Black Widow ends up being utile in stopping Whiplash , but you’re able to differentiate she ’s really only there to put in her part before the first Avengers film .
There ’s no other explanation why SHIELD would waste their top operative on playing Tony Stark ’s personal assistant . At leastAvengersfound her in the middle of an important commission interrogating weaponry dealers – Iron Man 2just has her babysitting Tony , hardly a task befitting her status . Any SHIELD undercover agent could ’ve done her Book of Job inIron Man 2 ; it ’s that far below her military rank .
She believes she’s a monster
Fans did n’t like Black Widow ’s attraction to Bruce Banner because it felt cast and sudden , but what really gear up hoi polloi off come later in the scene , when Widow started to explain why she felt Bruce was a kindred sprightliness .
Natasha emotionally talks about her yesteryear , her grooming as a spy by the Red Room , which culminated in her getting sterilized ( unable to have nestling ) . She compare this to the Hulk . Yeah , Black Widow ca n’t have kids , and somehow she recall this is comparable to turn into a artillery of aggregate destruction when you get furious .
Not only is it cockeyed to intend that Bruce worrying about whether he ’ll destroy a metropolis next time he receive wild is the same as Natasha not being able-bodied to have biologic children , it ’s not very reform-minded . Widow referring to herself as a " monster"because she ca n’t have kids is a pretty unimaginative , regressive interior struggle for a woman in the twenty-first century .
libber , intelligibly , carry issue with this , and the backlash has been labeled as a reason why Joss Whedon briefly get out Twitter ( which he hasdenied ) .
Regardless , the backlash point to the real issue here : it just does n’t make horse sense for the character . pitch-dark Widow seems to be beyond any concerns of a stable life , and here she is weeping because she ca n’t have tyke ? No path .
She should’ve been arrested after the events of Captain America: The Winter Soldier
This lend oneself to just about all of SHIELD , really . Captain America : The Winter Soldierfinds Cap , Black Widow , the Falcon , and Nick Fury all working frantically to undo the damage HYDRA has done to SHIELD .
The problem is , HYDRA did all this damage by infesting the government government agency from the interior , spreading its message and its loyal double agents throughout the whole organization . The bad guy cable derive within an inch of scoot millions of people around the world , thanks to SHIELD ’s Project Insight arming helicarriers with orbiting guns capable of neutralizing a thousand target a bit .
The heroes of the movie manage to stop this plot , but it does n’t let off them from the fact that they make a weapon that could so easily ruin so many lives .
The fact that the weapons immediately drop into the wrong hands , not to remark that those wrong hand were traitors they had work aboard for year , does n’t on the button put Black Widow , Nick Fury , and the rest of SHIELD in a benevolent light .
Black Widow somehow manages to win over a government investigation that she and SHIELD should still be trusted to save the world , but her account that they ’re the best certified campaigner does n’t really hold up . If an office had come seconds away from a state of war law-breaking unlike any else the world had ever seen , would you let the member of that agency appease destitute ?
She’s a ballerina - kind of
Superheroes be given to have a lot of wacky side jobs in the funnies , to protect their on-key identity . It was also a way for the writers to add together some flavor to the character , giving them some unexpected vocation in the real creation . Black Widow seems to have gotten the short end of that joint , though , as her cover caper provide a turn to be desired .
causa in point : Natasha Romanoff is canonically a highly trained danseuse . In a part of her backstory that even made it intoAvengers : Age of Ultron , Natasha was trained to be a ballerina as part of her in advance secretive KGB education .
Ballet was part of Widow ’s covering identity , which at this point is almost a parody of a Russian stereotype . A Russian undercover agent whose alter ego is a ballerina ? amount on . It get bad from there , though– in the comics , Widow afterward realise that her memory board of being a danseuse were in reality false implants put into her brain by her Soviet sea captain .
These retentiveness were put in her creative thinker to verify she stayed fast , so who knows , maybe her flashbacks inAge of Ultronto her days as a danseuse were false , too . candidly , we do n’t know which rendering is worse , the Russian stereotype of being a ballerina / undercover agent , or it being a prevarication all along– all we screw is that it does n’t make horse sense .
She lifted Mjolnir
At this detail , when you factor in all their " What If ? " storylines , who has n’t lift Mjolnir ? Well , the Black Widow from Earth-23223 has , and she put it to skillful purpose .
What If ? Age of Ultron#3 ( which is a real mouthful of a title ) recover Black Widow in Latveria , run with the Falcon to halt an intrusion of Frost Giants from Jotunheim . These Asgardian wight , and the Midgard Serpent Jormungand , threatened to destroy the public , so Widow live on a recovery commission to find Thor ’s hammer , Mjolnir . Then , somehow , she lift it .
Anyone who have a go at it Black Widow knows this does n’t really make sense . As a character , she is n’t even really concerned in it ( saying"that ’s not a question I involve answered"in the filmAge of Ultron ) . On top of that , it ’s more than a stretch to reckon she ’d be worthy to wield the power of Thor and become the Modern Goddess of Thunder with her chequer past and virtuously ambiguous mental attitude .
Even in a " What If ? " story , it just does n’t make sense .
The story conclude with Widow and heroes from other realities banding together to fight Ultron , but it ’s not really nerveless to see Widow with Mjolnir . It ’s mostly just peculiar .
