Related
We ’re slowly getting closer to the liberation ofFantastic fauna : The Crimes of Grindelwald . As the film premiere date nears , some fan are hold up back to the movie for a refresher . Or just a occasional rewatch , since they no longer run practically every weekend on ABC .
If it ’s been for a while since you ’ve rewatched any of theHarry Pottermovies – or for that matter , reread any of the books – you might realize that there are a few contingent that do n’t make any sense .
This is n’t a dig at JKR ’s world – she ’s hand us a high detailed , fantastically magic world to run in . There ’s a reason that the great unwashed are still dressing up as the characters for Halloween and gulping down butterbeer in Universal Studios . However , when you create such a braggart universe , there ’s bound to be a few mistake that slip through . Especially when you expatiate that universe to include a series of prequels that are n’t directly related to the original story .
Currently , there are ninePottermovies , seven books , a few scattered companion novel , and a play . We ’re taking a look at the entire Potterverse to add you this list of thing that do n’t make sense about the world of your puerility .
quick ? Read on for20 matter That Make No Sense About The Potterverse .
Villains don’t use the Unbreakable Vow
In the sixth book and film , we ’re introduce to the construct of the Unbreakable Vow . Unconvinced that Snape is in reality on their side ( for good intellect , as it turn out ) , Bellatrix forces him to make an Unbreakable Vow with Narcissa . As Ron explain to Harry later on , if you endeavor to break an Unbreakable Vow , you fall back your living . There ’s no financial backing out of it or double - crossing someone .
Given the nature of this spell , it ’s passably stupefying that supervillains like Voldemort and Grindelwald never used the Unbreakable Vow with their following .
Both of them were twist enough to where they would n’t handle if someone pall because they had a alteration of heart and decided not to follow order , and it would have prevented anyone from betraying them . Voldemort pack the clock time to brand each of the Death Eaters in his interior circle with the Dark Mark , so theoretically he also could have stopped to make the Unbreakable Vow with each one .
Even if he knew he had the undying dedication of someone like Bellatrix , there were others like Wormtail that he clearly did n’t intrust . As for Grindelwald , we ’ll likely strike more about the way of life he operated in this upcoming pic .
For now , though , it looks as though this was a pretty major supervising on their parts .
MACUSA sentencing
One of the things people were most excited to see in the firstFantastic Beastsmovie was what wizarding social club in the United States look like . Not only was the prison term period different – set in the 1920s instead of in the nineties – but we also buy the farm across the pond to New York .
New York also happens to be the home of MACUSA , or the Magical Congress of the United States of America . MACUSA is enshroud in plain sight in New York City , similar to the Ministry of Magic . Also similar to the Ministry of Magic , they seem to love pretend mere things more complicated .
Through a series of crook and change state duringFantastic savage , Newt and Tina are sentence to expiry after being wrongly accused of ending Henry Shaw . MostPotterfans were probably expecting someone to tie a sceptre and prove to cat Avada Kedavra before being stopped somehow . That method acting seems to make the most sense and is definitely the most effective .
MACUSA clearly had a in force thought , though , because they create an entire sleeping accommodation to stock out those sentences . As if that were n’t extra and melodramatic on its own , the bedroom also fundamentally work on in tedious movement , countenance for plenty of clock time for yardbird to be conveniently deliver .
maven literally invented a jinx to get this done quicker .
Sirius and Bellatrix get their wands back
The two polar - diametrical cousins both faced the same fate for a time – they were condemn to lifespan in Azkaban for charge crimes in the name of Voldemort . While Bellatrix was characteristically happy to be locked away , Sirius was falsely accuse . The only affair save him go was the sentiment of catch revenge on the actual culprit , Peter Pettigrew . Sirius was in Azkaban for twelve year , while Bellatrix had to string up out with the Dementors for an additional two years after her cousin manage to break out .
The two also have another thing in common – they somehow got their wands back after escaping .
captive in Azkaban are n’t allow to keep their wands after being doom and imprisoned .
It progress to good sense . If they could keep their wands , anyone who was capable to cast a decent Patronus Charm would be able to slip the prison guards and escape . We never find out where those wands are kept , but we can assume that they ’re either far away from the prisoners or destroy . Why would you hang onto the verge of someone who ’s supposed to be lag for life story ?
Yet , somehow , Sirius and Bellatrix both cease up with their wands back , and there ’s no path they could have just walked to Diagon Alley to corrupt a new one . It ’s never explained how they got their old baton back , other than they needed them for patch aim .
The Trace on underage wizards makes no sense
Speaking of all inept political science policies , one that we ’re introduced to betimes in the original series is The Trace . The Trace is meant to keep underage witches and whiz from perform conjuring trick without oversight and in Muggle area .
The Trace ca n’t in reality recite if the underage minor is the one performing the conjuring trick . All it report is if there ’s illusion being performed around someone who is underage . It ’s why the rescript goes to such extreme measures to get Harry out of Privet Drive .
This makes no sense for a portion of reasons . Any time there ’s a high concentration of witches and sensation somewhere – like in Diagon Alley or Hogsmeade , for example – there ’s no way of life of knowing whether it ’s a market keeper waving their wand or an eleven - year - erstwhile examination out their brand Modern possession .
If you have a charming parent at home , it ’s impossible for the Ministry to tell if a kid is practicing nonaged legerdemain . They have to bank on parents to sort out their kids . This intend that efficaciously , Muggle - born kids are the only one who in reality have to abide by the rules of The Trace .
If you ca n’t say who ’s casting the magic , then what ’s the degree of even having The Trace in the first place ?
Thestrals pulling carriages
InOrder of the Phoenix , we learn that the bearing are n’t actually pulling themselves . The “ horseless carriages ” are actually being pulled by thestrals , creepy horse - alike beast that can only be seen by those who have seen someone fall behind their life . Harry and Luna can see them , but the rest of the group can not .
destiny of people have question why Harry did n’t see them at the end of his quaternary twelvemonth , but Rowling has said it ’s because he had n’t emotionally processed the exit of Cedric yet and the occur needs to lapse in first . subsequently in the ledger and motion picture , the Thestrals amount in ready to hand when the six teens have to find a way of life to get to the Ministry .
One interrogation that is never answered is why Hogwarts is using these ominous creatures to pull their carriage in the first space .
Horseless carriage seemed totally plausible for so long because sorcerer have charm to make things move of their own volition . Why would you decide to use Thestrals of all affair to hale your students from wagon train place to castle ? Why not just charm the carriages ? It seems awfully morbid to have Thestrals taking the Kyd up the route to Hogwarts .
Hagrid belike had something to do with this .
Portraits are alive - kind of
One of the more puzzling look of the Wizarding World is the magic portrayal . While picture can move , they ’re more like GIFs – on a eyelet of prepare actions that do n’t leave their frames . portrayal , on the other hand , can interact with people , leave their frames to go talk to other paintings , and even crack jokes and give advice .
Many of the portraits were created in the likeness of a know somebody , like the former Headmasters of Hogwarts . Each Headmaster ( or Headmistress ) has a portraiture painted of them that appears in the Headmaster ’s spot after they pass on . They are then able to give advice to whoever the current leader of Hogwarts is .
This seems pretty cool , especially for those who have always yearned for any way to address to someone they ’ve lost . It also bring up a lot of doubtfulness . There ’s a part of that person ’s awareness in the portrayal - to a point . Before they pass away , the go national can teach their portrait authoritative detail they might call for to glide by on throughout history . They also seem to keep back the soul ’s personal manner of speaking and other of import personality traits .
It ’s not clear how powerful the portrayal are , though , or how they can give advice if they only experience a few contingent about their subject ’s life . Even Dumbledore ’s portrait is jolly undefended about his limitations when we see him inCursed Child .
It ’s really backbreaking to tell how ego - aware portraits are .
Wizards make things harder for themselves
One of the things that gives the Wizarding World its charm is that it ’s something all unlike than what we make out . Wizards can journey through fireplaces , play sports on broomsticks , and even choose to fall back as a ghost if they require .
Some of this conflict is because they ’re almost all trim back off from the Muggle worldly concern – after the Statute of Secrecy went into position , wizarding society became fairly isolated . That ’s even more obvious in the book , where we show about a man at the World Cup importune on wearing a nightgown because " Muggles fag them . "
That ’s one of the reasons why wizards do n’t know about many Muggle inventions , and Rowling also explained the Muggle tech goes haywire around deception . Some traditions that maven prevail onto , though , do n’t make any sense . Using a quill feather and parchment , for example , is neat for the aesthetic , but it has to be annoying dipping your quill ten thousand times to compose an essay .
magician have never heard of a ballpoint pen ?
Some aspects of modernistic Muggle company have clearly trickled into the Wizarding World – radios are somewhat common , for example , and the Ministry apply cars – so the press on keeping up with things that make life difficult does n’t make much sense .
The MACUSA President has no disaster plan
At the end ofFantastic Beasts and Where to ascertain Them , the virtuoso of New York City have a problem on their hands . Not only has Percival Graves just reveal himself to be dark wizard Gellert Grindelwald in disguise , but an Obscurus has been terrorizing the city and bollocks the Statute of Secrecy into smithereens .
The MACUSA President , Seraphina Picquery , is starting to actualise that they ’re in difficulty . Most of New York saw what materialise , and they have no way to wipe the memories of an entire city .
Luckily , Newt ’s Thunderbird is capable to control the weather , and can also carry a liquid version of the Memory Charm . This charming rain wipes exactly the correct memories of the No - Majs / Muggles , because it need to for the plot of land .
The wizard trouble - clear rainfall does n’t make much sense , but what really does n’t make sense is that MACUSA does n’t have a cataclysm plan . You never think to be after for a large - exfoliation event where many people were display to magic trick ? There was zero contingence programme there .
If Newt had n’t happen to be there with a bird he intended to release in Arizona , they all would have been screwed . It ’s pretty far - fetched to conceive that the government was wholly unprepared for something like this .
bad security department ever .
Giving a teenager the ability to control time
It was obvious from the moment Hermione Granger set foot on the Hogwarts Express that she was going to be one of the overbold people in the shoal . How many time has someone refer that she ’s the brightest witch of her age ? How many time has she proved it by salvage Harry and Ron from some trouble they get themselves into ?
It was obviously clear to the Hogwarts professors that she was surpassing , too , because they gave her the ability to command time so she could go to extra course of study .
Wait . What ?
No matter how precocious or gifted you think a thirteen - year - quondam miss is , or how many times she differentiate you that she ’s concerned in everything and wants to take extra classes , that does n’t have in mind you jump-start decently to giving her the ability to go back and forwards in clip . Professor Vector could n’t tutor her or something ? No one say , “ Hey , come by my federal agency and I ’ll play with you one - on - one if you really want to see this material ? ” There are n’t multiple section of classes offered ?
There is literally nothing that can make this make any sort of sense . Even adults do n’t have Time - Turners , and McGonagall give way one to Hermione so she could do her nine AM course of study twice .
The number of students in each house
Being screen into a sign of the zodiac is an of import part of the journey of every Hogwarts educatee . fit in to past and current students ( and the Hat itself ) , the Hat sees what ’s in everyone ’s head , but will also take personal preference into business relationship when Sorting fresh students . That ’s why Harry was able to opt Gryffindor as his business firm , and how he subsequently reassure his son Albus all those years later .
However , there seem to always be an even identification number of students in each house , which does n’t seem to hold up mathematically .
Why are there always perfectly even number of ambitious , ingenious , kind , and brave eleven - year - olds in each Hogwarts year ?
Is the Sorting Hat really taking personal preference into account , or is it secretly obsess with isotropy ?
It seems like it would be more logical to seize that some twelvemonth will have more Hufflepuffs than others , or perhaps one twelvemonth there was an influx of Slytherins and one lone Ravenclaw . It ’s pretty improbable that there ’s always exactly the same phone number of each fictional character trait for every house - peculiarly since they ’re classify eleven - yr - old child who are just starting to figure out who they are .
Something ’s off about the ratio here . At least it made for some groovy shot of the Great Hall .
