Related
To put it gently , theStar Trekreboot films are very dissentious for fans of the enfranchisement . On one hand , the reboots accomplished exactly what they set out to do : they madeStar Trek , a series that stereotypically focalize on introductory idea like exploration and heartsease , seem like an action serial alternatively . consequently , this helped bring in a fortune of casual viewers that would never antecedently have call themselves lover of Kirk , Spock , and the rest of the gang .
On the other hand , it ’s tough for this to not finger like a bit of a slap in the face to longtime fans of the franchise . Part of what makesTrekso nerveless is that its idea survive : whether you ’re watchingThe Original Series , Next Generation , orVoyager , you get the same basic kind of show which is arranged around the same basic , Utopian principles of dealership Jehovah Gene Roddenberry . To put it another way , Trekhas never tried to focus on being an action fomite , so why get going now ?
We ’re not here to settle that particular philosophical argumentation . However , we have pinpointed some moments from these rebooted picture that make no common sense .
Just keep scroll to read all about20 Things That Make No Sense About The Star Trek RebootMovies !
Enterprise Size
One of the big vanity of the reboot universe is that much of what we know and love is still the same on some storey . Kirk now has a tragic past times , but he still end up as a cocky skipper keep up his first , best destiny . Benjamin Spock is a moment more emo , but he ’s still an ultra - logical second in command . Then , there ’s theEnterpriseitself . To fooling rooter , it looks pretty recognisable — two nacelles , a saucer section , standardised colours , and so on . However , Trek fans with sharp centre noticed mighty away that the new design make no sense at all !
The independent proceeds : it ’s just too darn heavy ! fit in to information from the motion-picture show as well as the God Almighty , the fresh StarshipEnterpriseof Kirk ’s era is about as big as theEnterprise - Dwas under Captain Picard . This is ill-timed on so many degree . How and why does Starfleet suddenly have enough time , materials , and crowd to regularly fill ships that are so much larger than in theOriginal Series ?
The so - phone account for this is that Starfleet is prepare them bigger after encountering Nero ’s ship , but then why did the general figure stay the same ? It ’s crazy to still make a ship of exploration because you think you need ship of war !
From Cadet to Captain
Some of the items on this list are only frustrating if you are well - verse inStar Treklore . That ’s a civilized way of saying that these things made thoroughgoing sense to the fooling rooter who just amount to seeTrekas an action motion-picture show with comedic element , and it ’s only the hardcore buff who notice and complain . However , some things are so egregiously nonsensical that they pass on the full field of operations scrape up their heads . And one of those things was Kirk ’s sudden promotion .
Part of the new twist that the firstTrekreboot motion picture offered was that we saw Kirk and crew back in their academy twenty-four hours - with the exception of the seventeen year - old Chekhov who is inexplicably already an academy graduate , and Spock , who has had year to become the everlasting instructor ’s pet .
Kirk starts the movie as a civilian , becomes a plebe , and by the end , he is instantly promoted to Captain !
While it ’s true that he beat the bad guy and saved the satellite , Starfleet apparently decided that Kirk not only could skip the sleep of his academy age , but he could hop the decade or more it would have accept to mount up through the rank . Can you imagine the hard - work commander who lost a promotion so they could instantly promote a cadet above them ?
Why Didn’t Spock Approach Starfleet?
Once the great Leonard Nimoy was cast in the rebooted film , it was downright inevitable that we would see older Benjamin Spock interacting with the young versions of his former colleague . While those interaction roam from sweet ( as with Kirk ) to funny ( as with Scotty ) , reasonably much everything about how he meets them is mad .
First , there ’s the idea that Nero establish a habitable planet close enough to Vulcan that Spock could see his planet destruct . Then there ’s the idea that Kirk would be strand on that planet by untried Spock instead of just post to the brig . last , though , there ’s the activity of one-time Spock himself .
He do as though he planned to pass his intact life story in an ice cave until encountering young Kirk invest him back in the plot .
Specifically , Spock takes them both to the Starfleet base that Scotty is on , which thrust us to ask : why did n’t Spock go there on his own when he had the prospect ? You might think he just wants to preserve the timeline , but he ravage no time tell Kirk and Scotty about their future life . Would it have troubled him to go to the base as soon as he establish it and discourage Starfleet about Nero ?
Why build Enterprise in Iowa?
There are many accusations that fans have made against theTrekreboot films in ecumenical and J.J. Abrams in particular . One of the accusation is that these movies often focalise more on style than nub . While that may not always be straight , there is one scene that really stands out : when Kirk film his motorcycle out and see theEnterprisebeing built in Iowa .
The scene is regal and breathless as it shows off the stunner of theEnterprise . It ’s also completely and totally wrong !
One thing that has been reproducible aboutStar Trekover the course of many eld is that starships are establish in space . There are many hard-nosed reasons for doing this : it makes it easy to set up , both in footing of small-scale shuttle being able-bodied to manoeuver around the entire ship and those same shuttle being capable to carry materials through the weightless void of distance instead of the solemnity of Earth or another satellite .
As we mentioned before , theEnterpriseis absolutely huge — it ’s tough to reckon that lifting off would not whole ravage the area , even if they limited themselves to simple maneuvering thruster ! This scene exemplified the effect with reboots passably perfectly .
Why Is No One Surprised to See Romulans?
One path that theTrekreboots tried to shake thing up was by yield us a Romulan unfit hombre in the variety of Nero . While the Romulans made for memorable antagonists inThe Original Series , they never play a immense role in the movies based on the original series , and they sure as shooting were not the main adversary of any of those early films with Kirk and crew . Due to the clip - traveling shenanigans of the reboot , we get to see Kirk , Spock , and the others encounter a Romulan for the first meter ; an skirmish that makes no horse sense .
You might reckon there is a loophole here ( because Nero looks like the recent Romulans , gross with some weird os frontale ridging ) , but he still intelligibly declares himself as a Romulan , and neither the crew of the Kelvin or the crew of the Enterprise are surprised to see what a Romulan for what seems to be the first sentence .
Why is Spock so Much More Emotional?
The idea that Vulcans receive no emotion is something of a misconception , both in the reality ofStar Trekand in our own world . Vulcan can feel everything that humans experience , but they have made a cultural choice to conquer those emotions and operate strictly in the name of logic . Careful viewers ofThe Original Seriesknow that even Spock was n’t always ordered with this : he has been known to smile , call out in joy , and occasionally snap some loathsome jokes . But the emotion of the rebooted Spock basically make no sense .
In the spirit of give us untested , more eager versions of all of the familiarOriginal Seriescharacters , we get a Mr. Spock who is downright erratic .
He smarts off to the Vulcan Science Council , openly grieves over the loss of his mother , and practically croak Kirk out when he get angry .
On one helping hand , there are some huge mitigating factors : Spock is witness to the destruction of his world and the passing of his mother . However , the Spock we know would never act like this - something the film drives home by showing how older Spock go along his emotions in deterrent even after the destruction of Vulcan . fundamentally , young Spock is just constantly wild in that first reboot , and there ’s never a sound explanation .
Nero’s Motivations Make No Sense
On the admittedly generous scale of big screenTrekvillains , Nero is really moderately cool : he has a commanding comportment , a scarey ship , and he ’s ride by a bloody-minded agenda . Actor Eric Bana sells that bloodthirsty agenda so well that it ’s easy to get caught up in his performance . It ’s only after the credits start rove that you ’ll see yourself question several of the foundational aspects of his plot . unluckily , you ’ll be left with one inescapable ending : Nero ’s entire motivation make no common sense !
Basically , he blames Spock for the supernova that destroys his own homeworld of Romulus . We ’re conk to set aside the dubious scientific discipline of a supernova that travel the extragalactic nebula and concentrate instead on his motivation . Benjamin Spock is place on a mission to stop that supernova and save the Romulans , but he is ineffective to save them in prison term and gets send to the past tense , same as Nero . This mean that Nero blames Benjamin Spock for something that is not at all his fault ( it ’s a natural phenomenon ) , even as Spock was doing his best to help out .
Finally , Spock already pays for his failure by getting marooned in the past . The melodic theme that he needs to suffer more for his good purpose is passably much crazy talk of the town !
Where are the Time Cops?
The entire notion of “ rebooting”Star Trekrests on the idea of the altered timeline . The Romulan Nero ( and later , the old Spock ) come to the past and cut off thing , create a timeline that may have familiar characters ( like Kirk ) but whose events are not necessarily tied in to the Trek world that we know .
While this may work on the narrative level of want to produce a new sandpile for these movies , there is a pretty big scene ofStar Trekthat they are by choice overlooking .
There are multiple individuals and institution withinStar Trekthat monitor the timeline and are capable and uncoerced to fix it when things are askew .
Perhaps the most blatant example of this is the Department of Temporal Investigations . InDeep Space Nine , after Sisko and crew are unintentionally transported to Kirk ’s time , Sisko is call in by these temporal agents upon his return . While the instalment does n’t make it expressed , we intend it ’s just that such agents would have a manner of protect themselves from major changes to the timeline — otherwise , one small change wipe off them from history and forbid them from doing their job . However , no one seems to notice , precaution , or taste to prepare the monumental change triggered by this “ rebooted ” universe !
Transwarp Beaming
A plot constituent from the firstTrekreboot that divided fans concerned old Benjamin Spock and the Prime Directive . antecedently , Spock was a steadfast withstander of the directive and the overall idea that you should n’t interpose with the manner things are supposed to break . In this picture show , he seems to shrug and determine that because the timeline has already been change , he can say or do anything he wants to . For instance , he tells Scotty the recipe for “ transwarp beaming ” that older Scotty would later develop . Our question : why do we never see this technology again ?
Just to elucidate , transwarp beaming is amazingly powerful . Kirk and Scotty are able to send out from a remote frontier settlement near Vulcan and onto theEnterprise , even while the ship is traveling towards Earth at warp upper . This already seems like a universe - breaking technology ( why do you even postulate ships if you’re able to beam from one sector to another ? ) , but it ’s never seen again .
In shows likeStar Trek : The Next Generation , it ’s very clear that citizenry can not beam onto a ship at warp unless they match the accurate speed , and even then it ’s tricky . While this is an altered timeline , previous Spock insist that sr. Scotty developed this engineering science in the original timeline . So why is it never used ?
Why Hide The Enterprise Under Water?
Earlier , we discussed the idea that theseTrekreboots have an outcome with style over substance . This is very clear in the opening night ofStar Trek Into Darkness , in which we see Kirk and bunch trying to protect a crude alien species from being wipe out by a vent . Kirk later gets in raging body of water because he violates the Prime Directive double on this mission . First , the very routine of hold back a natural phenomenon ( a vent ) is forbidden . Second , to save Spock , he flies by and broadcast him out , giving the aliens a clear look at an advanced spaceship .
We can debate the morality behind Starfleet ’s Prime Directive another day because we have a more primal doubtfulness : why did Kirk veil the initiative underwater on this major planet ?
Scotty discourage him of all the reasons why this is a unfit idea , and the only good thing about it seems to be that it keeps the primitive aliens from consider the ship .
However , they are so primitive that they do not seem to have any electronic surveillance equipment of any kind . Kirk could have simply go along the enterprisingness in space and the natives would not ever see it . This would have been coherent ( as Spock might say ) but would n’t have given the movie its valued shot theEnterpriserising from the water .
