Captain America: The Winter Soldier
The Winter Soldier ’s popularity show any comics fiber can become a star if they ’re written right .
Bucky Barnes debut at the final stage of 1940 ( cover - dated 1941 ) as Captain America ’s chum . He never had a solo serial . When Marvel come to Captain America inAvengers#4 , they made it clear Bucky was not coming back , ever — he was pushing up daisies , he ’d joined the choir unseeable , he was an old-fashioned - surviving someone . None of that scream “ hotshot potential . ”
Neither , really , did Ed Brubaker resurrecting Bucky in 2005 . portion of comics writers , like Brubaker , revive or reboot characters based on childhood nostalgia . The results are rarely adept . Brubaker reinventing Bucky as the Winter Soldier , however , proved a decisive and commercial hit .
The MCU cemented the Winter Soldier ’s success . The relationship between Steve Rogers and Bucky Barnes works even better with two impregnable actor portraying it ; little marvel that so many fans steady down for more than friendship between them . True , Thanos erased the Winter Solder inInfinity War , but it ’s a dependable bet he ’s number back .
Like any character who ’s been around for almost 80 eld , the Winter Soldier does n’t always make sense . Some of that ’s the residue of the Golden Age , when writers did n’t occupy much about taradiddle logic . Some of it ’s the inevitable inconsistencies that accumulate over clock time . This does n’t make him any less of a nerveless fiber , but signal out the logic gaps in his history is still fun .
Here are20 Things That Make No Sense About The Winter Soldier .
His origin makes no sense
Ed Brubaker did n’t simply wrick Golden Age Bucky into the Winter Soldier , he retconned him to make his status as a world - class scourge more plausible .
In 1940 , Bucky was just a summer camp mascot when he trip up onto Steve Rogers identity . Naturally , Steve made Bucky his sidekick . In the retcon , that was propaganda — a illusion that any American kid could be a baddie - smashing superhero .
The world ? Bucky was a of course gifted scrapper , groom to even great accomplishment . He was Cap ’s phantom ego : if a guard had to be scrag or knifed from behind , Bucky involve care of it . No peril of defile Cap ’s figure by give birth him campaign contaminating . Would n’t reckon his young sidekick be that ruthless have the same electronegative PR impression ?
It ’s one part of the retcon that never made sense .
The Winter Soldier’s terrible at being stealthy
Superhero taradiddle have fuss write assassins well . It ’s hard to take them severely as threats when the heroes keep saving everyone they assay to terminate . They ca n’t be secret specter because the grinder ’s going to drag them into the spark and disclose them .
When Cap first get a line about the Winter Soldier , he learns the valet is an urban legend — nobody ’s sure he even exists .
feed the huge organic structure tally he ’s racked up , it ’s intemperate to see why people would n’t conceive in him .
In the MCU , the Winter Soldier ’s a “ ghost , ” a scourge who strikes from the shadows and vanishes . Except that would n’t suit the MCU style , so he ends up a ghost who leave a trail of explosions and end in his backwash .
His brainwashed relationship with Black Widow
Marvel Comics ' Winter Soldier had a much more colorful career than the picture show version . He eliminate Wolverine ’s married woman , and also had an affair with the Black Widow .
Along with take out enemies of the USSR , the Winter Soldier also train apprentice spies in the “ Red Room ” program . That included Natasha Romanoff . Along with teaching her , Bucky also became her quixotic partner , sometimes outsmarting security department to be with her .
If Bucky was a brainwashed monotone at this point , that ’s rather creepy-crawly ( though funnies have hadlots of creepy-crawly relationshipslike that ) . If he was n’t brainwashed , it ’s odd his masters did n’t put him back in cold sleep : Bucky recovering his detached will was one of their risky care .
Why did the Russians keep Bucky alive?
In the comic , Bucky ’s rescue by the Russians , not by Hydra . They ’re over the moon : Captain America ’s sidekick must have the tiptop - soldier formula in his body too , right ? Now they can extract it and create their own super - soldiers !
Oops . wrench out Bucky ’s just an ordinary fry , so they throw the consistency in a dumpster — no , hold off , that ’s what would seem logical .
For no discernible reason , they put him in cryo , even though they have no programme for him .
Nine years later they dethaw Bucky out , brainwash him and outfit him with his cyborg limb , but they did n’t have that in judgment earlier . There ’s no reason for preserving him other than the plot take it .
Nobody ever suspects that Bucky and Bucky Barnes are the same person
True , comics are a world where a brace of glassful can mask the world ’s neat sub . Even by those standards , Bucky ’s secret is flimsy .
severely , nobody ever noticed there was a kid named Bucky hanging around with Steve Rogers who looked just like the Bucky hanging around with Cap ?
He had nothing but a belittled mask to hide his face . This was n’t that unusual in the Golden Age : sidekicks Dan the Dyna - Mite and Pinky the Whiz Kid had secret personal identity name Dan and Pinky . 10 later it sift belief .
People make play of Lois for not watch through Clark Kent ’s meek - with - glasses disguise , but at least she had suspicions . In the MU , apparently nobody was up to her point .
Black Panther makes him the White Wolf
As MCU fans know , after Iron Man failed to give the sack Winter Soldier , Steve eventually omit him off in Wakanda . Shuri helped dismantleall those gun trigger commands and put his brain back together . When we see Bucky inInfinity War , he ’s fighting alongside the Wakandans . He is the White Wolf .
In the cartoon strip , the White Wolf was the drawing card of Wakanda ’s surreptitious intelligence armed service .
Why would Wakanda need or want an outsider in that position ? It ’s not like the Winter Soldier was a master spy — he ’s just a striking - man .
If it ’s his new superhero name , why piece one which has no particular significance for Africa — wolves are n’t as large there as in Europe or the US . Would n’t " Bucky " have forge just as well ?
He’s a Russian assassin with a patriotic American name
In create Bucky ’s raw ID as the Winter Soldier , Ed Brubakerdrew on American symbolism . He look up to the eighteenth - hundred patriot Thomas Paine , who compose dismissively of “ the summertime soldier and the sunshine patriot ” with no stomach for a hard fighting . Antiwar Vietnam veterans subsequently arouse Paine by portraying themselves as “ wintertime soldiers . ”
Bucky Barnes ’ Winter Soldier ID has no connectedness with American chronicle , though . He ’s a Russian macrocosm . Brubaker rationalise the Russians nibble the name because Bucky became an assassinator during the Cold War between the USSR and the USA . And the Russians keep Bucky wintry so much .
It ’s still a big coincidence . “ Iceman ” would have made just as much sense , but that ’s already taken .
His hit on the Starks
The braggart reveal ofCaptain America : Civil Waris that the Winter Soldier ’s history as a Hydra executioner include eliminating Howard and Maria Stark . Zemo reveals the truth to put down the Avengers and it ferment , setting Iron Man and Captain America against each other at the orgasm . It also makes no gumption .
We have the unlikelihood of Winter Soldier , the trace assassin , put the line of work right where a picture camera ’s conveniently watching .
Given the Winter Soldier is just a brainwashed Hydra dupe , why does n’t Tony at least deal that he ’s not really merit of elimination ?
Like most hero vs. hero comical - Bible battles , this one chooses spectacle over system of logic .
Tony makes him Captain America
After Captain America ’s termination in the MU’sCivil Warcrossover , Bucky has two goals . First , seize the shield so nobody can supersede Steve . Second , stop Tony Stark , whom he blames for the whole crossover . When Bucky confronts Tony , though , Stark yield Bucky a missive from Cap .
Steve does n’t require revenge — he wants Bucky to become the unexampled Captain America . Tony give Bucky the shield .
Which would make sentiency if it were Batman . But Captain America is a government agent , operating under federal authority – the idea he needs to show with the administration inCivil Warwas just dumb . He ca n’t simply will the shield to Bucky like a kin heirloom .
But hey , nothing else made sense aboutCivil War , so why quibble ?
His hair
Stan Lee once compliment Jack Kirby by say nobody else could have drawn Thor with articulatio humeri - length blond hair and convinced early sixties kid he was a real piece . Shoulder - duration fuzz was “ hair like a girl . ” It was too feminine for guy rope back then , inviting parody and intimidation .
The same was true back in 1944 , when the Russians placed Bucky into cryo - sleep . Yet somehow Bucky seems perfectly well-to-do wearing hair that long . No conflicts with his common sense of masculinity whatsoever . He in all likelihood did n’t have much of an opinion on it as a Russian sleeper , but now ?
Of course , it ’s a great feeling for him , and fan no longer have a problem with it . It ’s not surprising he has n’t brought up the subject .
