Related
The first reviews for director Adam Wingard and Netflix’sDeath Notesuggest that the film is yet another lively - action anime movie adaptation misfire . Wingard’sDeath Notefollows on the heels of director Rupert Sanders’Ghost in the Shelllive - action movie from earlier this year . That Scarlett Johansson - led film was both a vital and commercial dud , but did help to shine a limelight on the longtime , larger conversation aboutwhitewashing anime / manga propertiesand the difficulty of translating Japanese comic Word of God stories into America - based narration , in the first place .
Death Note ( 2017 ) , as was scripted by Jeremy Slater ( co - author of the 2015Fantastic Fourreboot ) , ask office in Seattle and revolves around one Light Turner ( Nat Wolff ) , a magnificent teenaged foreigner who happens upon a mysterious notebook that pass its user the power to toss off anyone whose name they compose down in it . Light , with the help of his familiar high schoolerMia Sutton ( Margaret Qualley ) , in act decides to use his newfound " Death Note " to free the streets of his metropolis of crime , by kill off one practice of law - breaker after another . However , Light ’s vigilante actions soon appeal the attention of both the constabulary and a extremely - intelligent , if quirky and enigmatic tec know as simply " L " ( Lakeith Stanfield ) .
Wingard and Netflix’sDeath Notewas first screened for the general populace at this year ’s San Diego Comic - Con , well in the lead of the picture ’s premiere on the streaming service later this calendar week . The first wave of reviews forDeath Noteare now online and , as betoken earlier , the initial critical consensus is negative at the time of writing this . To learn are n’t digging the picture show , take on for somespoiler - freeexcerpts from the firstDeath Notereviews ( and click the corresponding link , if you require to read the reviews in full ) .
The Wrap- Inkoo Kang
The filmmaker throw in some usual Hollywood pap about the peril of vigilante justice and the seductions of inviolable power , but those flimsy content fly in the typeface of the rest of the film . Nor are the death fun or suspenseful to check - funny for a horror helmer like Wingard , who directed such well - received literary genre fare as “ You ’re Next ” and “ The Guest . ” Save for the denouement atop a ferris rack , the whole picture reeks of paycheck solicitation .
Indiewire- David Ehrlich
The only reason to take such a uniquely Japanese story and transplant it to Seattle is to explore how its thorny moral questions might inspire unlike answers in an American context , so for this retread to all but reduce America to its innocence indicates an absence of setting more than anything else . It ’s the most glaring symptom of a film that utterly fail to investigate its premise , a film that wastes a handful of goofy performance and a gluttonous point of hyper - violence in the service of a total dead end .
Polygon- Julia Alexander
Death Note ignores its characters , prefer to put its emphasis on the physical horrors associated with the notebook - that - kills instead of the psychological drama that develops around it . [ The original anime ] is turned into a running play - of - the - John Stuart Mill American horror moving picture , and not a right one . It would be one thing if Death Note managed to action its goal of taking another estimation and morphed that into an interesting , esthetic - driven repulsion , but that ’s not what [ the film ] does . [ It ’s ] a lazy , ambitionless , forgettable motion picture that miss any imaging , heart or entertaining values .
Slant Magazine- Clayton Dillard
As more shadowy anatomy and exposition are wedged into the film to satisfy fans of the source textile , Wingard lose storage area of his initially distinct central construction of a globally inclined crook duet fuel by a strange love affair score to pop euphony and thriving on violence . Whereas the more grounded setting of Death Note , whether in Light ’s home or at school , anchor a startlingly crashing fantasy of world power run amuck , the scenes that fixate on super powers and codification - busting seldom manage to resurrect above the realm of serviceable YA fiction .
myriametre Buzz- Dave Golder
Like the late US remake of Ghost in the Shell , this Netflix interpretation of Death Note is likely well avoided if you have a go at it the original source material … However , if you ’re newfangled to this story , somewhat much everything that ’s good about this cinema - apart from some delightfully ghastly end … are the thing forget intact from the manga … Less successful is the film ’s tone , which wavers precariously between John Hughes funniness and Final Destination and is never peculiarly comical or particularly scary .
IGN- Blair Marnell
Death Note add together more adolescent melodrama and condense the story of the original manga in a room that is n’t always fulfill to take in . While the conduce falter , the sustain shape whole tone up in a prominent way to keep their portion in the movie grounded and entertaining . Willem Dafoe ’s Ryuk was an absolutely prompt piece of casting , and he well carried his scenes . If there is a continuation , work him back as Ryuk is a must .
alike to the criticism ofGhost in the Shell , theseDeath Notereviews suggest that Wingard ’s movie struggles to adapt its Japanese root textile in a coherent manner and lacks the innovative flourishes that led to the filmmaker ’s earlier repulsion genre throwbacks ( You ’re NextandThe Guest ) becoming both critical pet and fan - favourite within the horror / thriller residential area . However , whereasGhost in the Shellwas taken more to task for keeping the Nipponese context of its source material but featuring a primarily white cast , it sounds as thoughDeath Note ’s whitewashing issue are as much thematic as surface - tier . In other Son , it seems that the movie only give out to see a way for this narration to resonate as strongly in a U.S.-setting as it does in a Japanese one .
It ’s not all doom and glumness forDeath Notethough , found on what critics are pronounce thus far . Most everyone seems to agree thatWillem Dafoe as Ryuk- the " Death God " who own the Death Note and passes it onto Light in the write up - is an divine bit of casting , while some critic are also giving Wingard credit rating for having produce some uniquely gruesome horror / thriller specify pieces here . The general outlook towards the film could start to amend once more people have seen it too , peculiarly among those who have no prior knowledge of theDeath Notefranchise . For those whoaredie - hardDeath Notefans , unfortunately , it sounds like this re - interpreation probably is n’t going to be your cup of afternoon tea .
NEXT: Why the Death Note Trailer Disappointed Fans
seed : Various ( see the above contact )
