Related
sports fan ofHarry Pottertake great ownership of the news report tell by the novel , films , stage play , and spin - offs the franchise has move over so far . With so much to squander in this rich , complex , intemperately populated wizarding world established by authorJ.K. Rowling , it was inevitable that Potterheads from around the macrocosm would fill in certain blank with their own imaginations , creating rooter theories online that , finally , made their way to the mainstream medium and J.K. Rowling herself .
But while many fan theories are beautiful , aspirational , and enrich to theHarry Potterseries , some are just altogether wild hypothesis that have little to do with reality , as the author has point out sentence and time again . Thanks to her active social medium presence , J.K. Rowling has kindly strike the time , in many different example , to dispel some of these dubious ( and sometimes scornful ) theories that Potterheads produce in their … well , heads .
As theFantastic wildcat and Where To Find Themprequel serial of five movies will stick in the young variant to some of our favoriteHarry Pottercharacters , we can bear that even more hypothesis will be dismissed , confirmed , or created to make sensory faculty of this wizarding world .
For now , however , these are15 Fan Theories Rejected By J.K. Rowling .
RON IS THE TIME-TRAVELING DUMBLEDORE
In 2004 , a strange theory was brought up byHarry Potterfans who exchanged ideas through online forums : what if Ron Weasley was just the fourth dimension - travel Dumbledore ?
In the mail service that originated this theory , fans indicate that Harry often referred to both Dumbledore and Ron as mass who were thin , tall , and had a long nose . Fans also point out that both part had a strong passion for sweets , and that it was quite odd for Dumbledore to know on the nose what Ron had reckon for himself in theMirror of Erised .
The strongest tilt for the devotee theory , however , is the fact that Dumbledore always seemed to know with a richness in detail about everything that ever happened to Harry , Hermione , and Ron … almost as if he was there all along .
Though it actuate curiosity , J.K. Rowling shut out this possibility down in a 2015 tweet contain only two words : “ false possibility . ”
The CURSED CHILD IS A PREQUEL
On June 26 , 2015 , J.K. Rowling took to Twitter to share the exciting news that theHarry Potterfranchise would find a new storytelling sales outlet in London ’s West End theater circuit . She announcedHarry Potter and the Cursed Childwith a series of tweet that confirm the shimmer ’s opening escort ( in 2016 ) and quisling ( writer Jack Thorne and director John Tiffany ) .
On the very same twenty-four hours , JKR tweeted : “ However , I can say that it is not a prequel . ” Hours afterwards on that very same 24-hour interval , she tweet again : “ NOT a prequel . lot of citizenry call for , so I think I ’d say that again ! NOT a prequel . ” Then , on the next day , the author tweet twelve more times aboutCursed Childnot being a prequel .
Like Harry himself , the prequel theory somehow survived . month after the announcement of the play , J.K. Rowling was still try out to reject thatCursed Childwas a prequel . In an October 2016 tweet , she replied to a rooter who require the same freaking prequel question ( and even predict her ambiguous ! ): “ This is a joke , right ? Please ( sobs ) , please evidence me this is a prank . ”
DRACO IS A WEREWOLF, SNAPE IS A VAMPIRE
This isn’tTwilight , cat .
There was a fan possibility ( and even a DracoMalfoyIsAWerewolf.com website for it ) that seek to argue that Draco is really a lycanthrope . The basis for this theory is that the character reference change a lot in books 6 and 7 , remark that Fenrir Greyback ( an genuine werewolf ) is a close admirer , and that at one point Voldemort suggests that Draco should “ babysit the cubs . ” The devotee go as far as imagining that Draco probably bank directly on Snape to have admission to wolfsbane potions in club to keep his werewolf prison-breaking under control .
On that note of hand , there is an add - on theory that also claim that Snape is probably at least partially a lamia , and the entire reasoning behind it is because the prof state his educatee duringPrisoner of Azkabanto turn in essay on how to make out and stamp out a werewolf . Because , you get it on , lamia and werewolves are longstanding contender , so that has to be the logical finish , right ?
Nope . As a matter of fact , J.K. Rowling tweeted out that she had never even heard of this hypothesis before 2015 , and that Draco was definitely not a werewolf ( nor was Snape a lamia ) .
HARRY IMAGINED THE WHOLE THING
suffer , Friends , The Matrix , Harry Potter , you name it . There ’s always the “ it was all a dream ” possibility , is n’t there ?
In a behind - the - scene consultation forThe Harry Potter Wizards ’ CollectionDVD boxful set , J.K. Rowling and screenwriter Steve Kloves talked about being careful in their own writings for people to not chute to the conclusion that Harry was imagining things . Kloves refer that in an early draft of his handwriting forThe Sorcerer ’s Stone , Harry would talk to a spider inside his cupboard , and that he removed sealed scene of that context so that audiences would n’t call into question Harry ’s saneness once Hagrid appeared .
J.K. Rowling agreed with Steve Kloves that it was important to tug that point in the book , particularly since she had heard more than once that lover theorize about Harry imagining the entire series up . basically , this hypothesis is just not unfeigned .
NEVILLE AND LUNA END UP TOGETHER
Many fans like to imagine that Neville Longbottom and Luna Lovegood would one mean solar day end up together . There is even a famous online fan fiction fib calledNeville and Luna : Forbidden , in which kinky Luna and incompetent Neville would encounter their way to one another and start an unlikely yet meet wild-eyed partnership .
It was very common forHarry Potterfans to “ ship ” couples that the series did not otherwise allude to , such as Dean Thomas and Seamus Finnigan , or Xenophilius Lovegood and Professor Sprout , or even Dobby and Kreacher .
While J.K. Rowling never directly addressed any of these particular fan theories , she did advert in a Bloomsbury live chat in 2007 that , in the hereafter , Luna Lovegood married someone named Rolf , who isNewt Scamander ’s grandson .
HARRY, HERMIONE, AND RON NEVER FINISHED THEIR STUDIES
The notorious Battle of Hogwarts , which defeated Voldemort and his Death Eaters , was pretty distracting forHarry Potterfans , Hogwartsstudents , and the Wizarding universe as a whole . However , there is one more thing the general world tends to block about : because of the Battle , Harry , Hermione , Ron , and all other Hogwarts students had their studies interrupted , which mean that many of them seemingly never had the luck to terminate their 7th yr in peace and graduate from shoal .
In an interview withPotterCastin 2007 , J.K. Rowling addressed the theory that neither Harry , Hermione or Ron actually had the probability to calibrate from Hogwarts . According to the author , after the Battle was over and Hogwarts resumed its normal functioning , Hermione did go back to school to stop her written report . Harry and Ron , however , did indeed go on to be grownup lives without expire back to school .
CURSED CHILD WILL BE TURNED INTO A MOVIE
Potterheads around the world who ca n’t give to go to London to watchHarry Potter and the Cursed Childin the West End theatre circuit are eager to cohere to any hypothesis or hearsay that the point romp might be turned into a motion-picture show . However , harmonize to a very recent post from J.K. Rowling on her personal website , there are definitely no conversations of that kind go on .
The author like a shot addresseda rumor that bait a theorizedCursed Childmoviebeing released in 2026 , and that it had already confirmed the main trio of actor ( Daniel Radcliffe , Emma Watson , and Rupert Grint ) to reprise their roles as Harry , Hermione , and Ron .
Rowling tried to tug her point across very clearly , severely stating that there are no plan to turn this prop into anything else other than a romp . “ No plans for it to become a moving picture , a novel , a puppet show , a cartoon , a comic book series orCursed Child on Ice , ” she save .
J.K. ROWLING IS ACTUALLY RITA SEEKER
There is literally a fan hypothesis that sample to prove that Rita Seeker , a famous journalist in the wizarding world , was exile from that community and wrote theHarry Potterbooks under the J.K. Rowling nom de guerre to expose the existence of champion to muggles .
The sheer existence of J.K. Rowling as a real person disdain the validity of this fan theory . Joanne Rowling was born in Yate , Gloucestershire ( England ) in 1965 . She earned a B.A. from the University of Exeter in 1986 . Her mother , Anne , croak in 1990 , which is the same class when Rowling set out to conceive theHarry Potterseries . She has three fry – Jessica , David , and Mackenzie – and is matrimonial to Neil Murray , a doctor .
apart fromHarry Potter - related employment , J.K. Rowling has so far published four grownup novel : The Casual Vacancy , The Cuckoo ’s vocation , The Silkworm , andCareer of Evil .
FAWKES IS A DUMBLEDORE HORCRUX
J.K. Rowling really dislike the theme that anyone would think that Dumbledore , of all mass , would ’ve created a Horcrux throughFawkes , his beloved Phoenix .
Making a Horcrux require murdering someone in sacrifice , fragmenting your person into a disjoined thing , and ultimately , turning that thing ( a being or an objective ) into something evil .
The idea that Dumbledore would be interested in that procedure is enough to make a real fan ’s eyes roll , and when Fawkes is wreak into circumstance – a phoenix that Dumbledore had so much love life and admiration for – it all just becomes even more disturbing .
In a 2016 tweet , J.K. Rowling responded to thisHarry Pottertheory in a unclouded and concise path : “ the theme that anybody believes this is strangely upsetting to me . ”
HARRY AND HERMIONE ARE SIBLINGS
It is strange to think of it now , but back when theHarry Potternovels and pic were still being issue , many fans were starting to believe that the reason Hermione was n’t romantically concerned in Harry is because they were on the Q.T. siblings .
The theory also gained durability from the fact that Hermione seemed to have sex way too much about Harry upon their first group meeting , and though he was a fame in the wizarding domain , she find highly prosperous around him .
However , according to a J.K. Rowlinginterview in 2014 , the author admitted to the fact that Hermione should ’ve probably ended up marrying Harry instead of Ron , and even questioned whether Ron was going to make her happy in the farseeing test after all .
The fact that J.K. Rowling made a hard decision to have Hermione get hitched with Ron ( alternatively of Harry ) very directly eliminate the notion that there was any possibility that she was actually Harry ’s sis . Unless Rowling was take notes fromGame of Thrones , which does n’t seem to be the casing .
