Related
Since its release in the tardy 1990s , the history of the son who lived has captivated audience worldwide . Harry Potteramassed a monolithic fanbase , one which was only significantly increase by the movie adaptations and marketing . The wizarding world of Harry Potter has quite a large account of lore behind it , being one of the large mankind to descend out of a fancy novel in the last few decades . The world of Harry Potter was instantly popular and has sent fans on a craze to divulge the secrets cover beneath the story ’s nook and crannies . now and again , they ’ve found some things that do n’t quite bring up .
In the vast setting of these novel and motion-picture show , there ’s confine to be some inconsistencies somewhere along the line . Whether it be between the al-Qur’an and motion picture or their own disjoined entities . Of naturally , for as big of a role as the Potter family roleplay in these news report , they are not nontaxable from fans looking to put the pieces together . It ’s only natural that there would be somethings found about the famous family that would wrack your brainiac a short .
Here are15 Things That Do n’t Make Sense About The Potter Family .
Harry Having No Other Living Family Besides The Dursleys
Harry Potter is one of the most tragic fictional character in all modern fable . His parent were eliminated by Voldemort , half of the schooltime perishes for him ( spoilers for an eight - year - former conclusion ) and he has to expend his young life live with his last living descent relatives , the Dursleys . in force ol' Aunt Petunia and Uncle Vernon take him in quite begrudgingly , plow him like dirt due to his unnamed wizardly blood line , while spoiling their Logos Dudley until his head is as big as a Whomping Willow . Enduring years and years of sleeping in a closet under the stairs would do a mint to someone , but amazingly Harry turn out alright when his alphabetic character to Hogwarts came . However , did he really have to put up all that abuse ? In a family as big as the Potters , were there really no others that could take him in ?
Seriously , there was no distant relative that Harry could have stay with ? Not even a first cousin Bob ?
According toPottermore , Harry ’s ancestors were all only children , but there is no reference of cousins or other branches of the class that could be account for . With a family as big and vibrant as the Potters , it ’s hard to believe that the only one even blood connect was Harry ’s ma ’s sister . If he had just one first cousin or great auntie or another family member of some kind out there , then he could have spring up up without the horrifying experience of live with the Dursleys . He also might not have turned out to be such a compassionate and caring fibre , if he had not brave out those rigourousness so , possibly it was for the good .
The Age Of James Potter’s Parents
It ’s an account , but not one that makes a heap of sense . It ’s dead normal for people to live that long ( as Harry ’s grandparent were bear before the 1900s and make pass away in 1979 ) . However , it ’s very incredibly rare to have a baby so late in life-time . James was born in 1960 which means that his parent would have been well into their late years , much past the time of having a child . While this might be unfeigned for humans , perhaps their magical roots is what allowed them to have a son so much later in lifetime . It has never truly been explain how by either the books or the author , so for now we ’ll just have to utilise our imaginativeness . It ’s what Rowling would have want after all .
Harry’s Eye Color Is Different From His Mom
This one is more of an inconsistency in the movies than the al-Qur’an . It ’s something that has long since had rooter irritated , while not make any sentiency . In the books , Harry is key as having a thin case , messy fatal haircloth and hopeful green eyes . Throughout the different entering in the serial publication , characters often comment on how Harry has the exact same eyes as his mother . A trait which is normal for a son to have picked up from his mother . Once the movies came around and the role of Harry Potter was given to Daniel Radcliffe , the gang agnise one difference . He had down in the mouth eye instead of green . Well , no biggie , right ? He can just wear dark-green colored contacts to gibe with the characters pedigree . Nope !
Tomato , Tomahto . drab eyes , brown eyes . Same difference .
Turns out Radcliffe was allergic to the contact , a condition in which the crew just had to settle . Still , no freehanded deal . Changing his eye color was n’t something that grown that fans would complain about . They can just give his mom down in the mouth eyes as well ! However , fans were lit up when the child that was sick as his mother had brown eyes or else . It ’s very possible that it ’s a item the crew might have just forgot , with film circle being very busy . But , as much as his eye colour is mention , with it being his rival Professor Snape ’s dying words , it was an unforgiveable error for some fans . His center color is the one man of himself that others see his mother in . Would it have really been that toilsome to determine an actress with downhearted eyes ? C’m on Warner Brothers .
James Exiting Voldemort’s Wand First
The end ofThe Goblet of Firewas incredibly acute . It featured Harry falling into a hole set by his arch nemesis Voldemort , who further seize the new boy and employ him to return to his former world power . After killing Cedric Diggory , Voldy challenges Harry to a affaire d’honneur in an attack to humiliate him . This does n’t quite work out in the means Voldemort had hoped . Due to both of their wands bear the same core , they are referred to as brother wands . When two blood brother wand go fountainhead to principal , they create a reverse spell effect have it away as Priori Incantatem . This causes the spells cast by one of the wands to put out a shadow of patch it had late cast , part with the most late magic spell first . To put it in simpler condition , when these two wand match , all of the go are free as “ shadows ” in reverse guild . patently , Voldemort had been doing a flock of life story taking before his frustration , so his duel with Harry lead in his most late victims uprise from his verge .
The inconsistency comes in the order . Throughout the books , James had been described as losing his life history before Lily when Voldemort fall to take Harry Potter . If that is the showcase , Lily should be first to rise from the wand , before James . However , the book describes James as being the first to leave the baton , a fact inconsistent with what the book had said previously . This led many to believe that J.K. Rowling was revealing a hugger-mugger true statement about the Potter ’s go past out , but the generator insists the misunderstanding came fromwriter ’s weariness . These books are pretty long you have it off !
The Potters Trusting Peter Pettigrew With Their Secret Location
Upon memorise that they had a office on Voldemort ’s listing as his next victim , Lily and James Potter decided to go into concealing to keep their newborn son , Harry , away from the demon . To keep their placement a closed book , the distich range a Fidelius Charm . The Fidelius Charm is a spell that supply the caster ’s location inconspicuous , untraceable and soundproof . There ’s a catch though . In order for the while to work , the knowledge of the secret must be kept with someone called the ‘ secret keeper . ’ This information is then magically mesh within the secret keeper ’s soul and can not be known unless the steward chooses to divulge it volitionally . In choose a mystical steward for their fix , the Potters prefer Peter Pettigrew as they believed this pick would drop off Voldemort . When Pettigrew turns out to be a blackleg ( literally ) for the dark lord , their secret is exposed and Voldemort afterwards eliminates them .
Never trust a rat .
While their alternative makes sense in hypothesis , it does n’t make sense according to the nature of the tour . The Fidelius Charm can only be gift voluntarily and can not be loose if the custodian is being threatened or tortured . This entail that if the closed book had gone to any of the Potter ’s other closelipped admirer , such as headmaster Dumbledore , Voldemort would not find out unless Dumbledore wanted to tell him . They had chosen to go with Pettigrew as they believed it would have off Voldemort and keep their protagonist safe . However , they could have easy kept hidden if one of their friends want to be a sacrifice for them . It was a mistake that be them their lives , but put the floor into motion for their famous son .
All The Potters Being Placed In Gryffindor
When students arrive at Hogwarts every year , they are place into one of four dissimilar house . Kind of like a frat for virtuoso . These houses admit Hufflepuff , Ravenclaw , Slytherin and of row , Gryffindor . Students are not permit to pick home , or else that is the duty of the Sorting Hat . The Sorting Hat is a very old hat created by the founders of the four houses and sorts students into their tidy houses based on their traits . The chapeau is place on a pupil ’s head and can take anywhere from a second to five minutes to resolve where the student should be placed , promptly shouting the theatre they go to from its cloth sassing . It can read a pupil ’s thoughts and have a conversation with them . Though often very accurate in its sorting , the chapeau has been get laid to make occasional errors . But , it will always back its original choice .
When Harry arrived at Hogwarts , he was sorted in Gryffindor after some circumstance , a pick which the hat made for his begetter and root before him . The hat considered target him in Slytherin too , a choice which was ultimately made for Harry ’s son . But , how do all the Potter boys terminate up being put into Gryffindor ? The trait of a Gryffindor are brave and fearless , but somewhere along the pedigree one of the boy would have had to let out the mold . They ca n’t all reach that description , but for a long time many of them did . It just does n’t make sense how so many of them in a dustup could all go to the same house .
The Potter Men Having To Wear Glasses
Throughout the Book , many of the Potter human including Harry and his daddy are described as having regretful eyesight and having to wear glasses . While this is n’t an rare trait for most part , it does n’t make a whole lot of sense when your characters are wizards who belong to to a society that has unwrap solutions to the most unremarkable of job . If they are able-bodied to educate a potion that can heal Harry ’s broken arm , then they sure have something for his eyesight or any other perceived flaw for that matter . So , if he could mend his sightedness , why did n’t he ?
The Potter were the original hipsters , they wore glasses before it was cool .
The cause could be that he just did n’t desire to . Since enchantress and wizards all have the ability to fix the “ fault ” about themselves , such as eyesight , hairsbreadth , weight , they could make the perfect edition of themselves . At least physically . They just might not have want to fix these thing to keep their identity . Wizards care about more than just appearances ! They very much value their more interior traits and are n’t as focused on the exterior . With as much as Harry had break on to worry about , he probably did n’t even stop to remember about what he looked like . Another explanation has been pass on by J.K. Rowling . She saidthat her choice to give Harry deoxyephedrine come from her being timeworn of characters with frames being portray as head . Way to gravel up for the little guy J.K. !
The Dursleys Extreme Dislike of Harry
As we discussed in the beginning , Harry ’s aunty and uncle were not his biggest fan . They made him slumber in a cupboard under the stair as well as perpetually berating him . Since Harry was delivered to the Dursleys when he was just an infant , you would think they would treat him more like their own son , yet they almost came to the power point of disowning him . It make no sense that they would give him so much sorrow when he had done nothing to them antecedently . One could debate that they ’re just cruel like that , but then that would n’t explain why they spoiled their Logos Dudley to the bone . No , their dislike of Harry has to come from deep roots .
In a post published onPottermore , J. K. Rowling explain that Aunt Petunia had always been jealous of her sis Lily ’s magical abilities when she herself possessed none of them . She was even rejected by Dumbledore when she wrote an admittance letter to Hogwarts . This disfavor was driven even further by an unpleasant get together between James Potter and Uncle Vernon . That lead in the couple distancing themselves from the Potter house until Harry showed up at their doorsill . This disfavor of Aunt Petunia ’s more magical side of the family unit and Uncle Vernon ’s contempt for anything out of the ordinary became the footing for why they would treat Harry as bad as they did . While these are their cause , it still does n’t seem quite fair to take out what problem you had with someone on their child , but such is the style of phantasy lit .
Albus Potter Being Sorted Into Slytherin
Like discussed earlier , the Potter men are infamous for being sorted into Gryffindor house . It derive as a surprise when Harry ’s Logos Albus was sorted into Slytherin inHarry Potter and the Cursed Child . He was finally the mordant sheep to break the Gryffindor streak , but in a surprising move . Could Harry ’s boy really have the qualities of the house that his puckish nemesis Voldemort was once placed in ?
A member of the Potter family was bound to go into a separate household , but Hufflepuff or Ravenclaw , not Slytherin ! Why Albus , why !
While it is never entirely explain in the story , there are a few things that could justify his sorting into Slytherin house . First of all , Albus has a big legacy to live up to . He is the son of ‘ the boy who lived . ’ Harry went down in story as one of the most famous and gifted wizards of all time and that by default put a lot of pressure on Albus . When he began his first twelvemonth at Hogwarts , Albus was not very good at magic . This resulted in Albus being tormented and insulted by his friends , many of which were already amused that a Potter was put into Slytherin house . second , on his way to Hogwarts , Albus becomes supporter with Scorpius Malfoy , the son of Harry ’s bitter challenger Draco Malfoy . Scorpius expresses his desire to be sort out into Slytherin just like his father . When the two boy strike up a friendship , Albus ’ sorting could very well come from his desire to be in a house with a friend , much like Harry becoming booster with Ron and being separate into Gryffindor .
Albus’ Use Of Time Travel
clip travel in any narrative is always a confusing concept . take care at any of the multiverse story from the past forty year of comics and hear to say it is n’t perplexing . Of course , as with most phantasy epos , especially one about adept , Harry Potterwas bound to dabble in the conception at some point . InHarry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban , they did dabble with meter travel . However , unlike most stories , they dabbled responsibly . In the story , Harry travel back in fourth dimension to save his past self and Sirius Black from Dementors by conjuring a Patronus , a missionary post which proves successful . Thus , Harry operates in a closed time grommet , a loop in which the past times is pendant on the future which is dependent on the past . Confusing right ? It gets even worse when Dumbledore emphasizes the dangers of your past self seeing you , rabies and a disturbed metre grommet that does n’t lead in the creation of the present you make out from .
While time travel is dabble with in theHarry Potterseries , it is a major game point inThe Cursed Child . Time traveling is very much warned against in this story and although there are several repercussions from Albus Potter travel back in time , there is one scene in which it is inconsistent . At the news report ’s culmination , Albus and Scorpius travel to the nighttime in which Harry ’s parents were have out and attempt to stop Voldemort ’s daughter Delphi from kill Harry . All of this materialize with no major effect to the present , in all likelihood due to Harry ’s further involvement . But it is very inconsistent with how they were able to mess with a mo so crucial and have everything bend out just fine .
