Related
The story of theHarry Potterseries focused on the titular boy wizard , alongside his two unspoiled friends ; Hermione Jean Granger and Ronald Bilius Weasley .
The fact that the story focuses on Harry , Hermione , and Ron means that they are often the focal pointedness of the mistake that have creep into the series .
We mostly saw the world ofHarry Potterthrough Harry ’s eyes , so the bulk of the inconsistencies go around around the action of his peers .
The world ofHarry Potteris fulfill with magic and monster , but the rules that govern these mystical elements do n’t always make sense and are n’t always consistent with each other .
The inaccuracies stack up as the Holy Scripture went on , especially inThe Deathly Hallowswhen a crew of new rules for magical wands was added out of nowhere .
TheHarry Potterseries ' original intended audience was children , but as it found mainstream success , the textual matter started to be approximate through an grownup lens . The inconsistent rules of the magical universe would in all probability wing over the head word of a kid , but they were obvious to the critical optic of an grownup .
This extend to J.K. Rowling answer some of the questions about the series on her old site and onPottermore , some of which were intended to patch up the voice of the series that did n’t make sense .
We are here today to discover which portion of the most famous literary trinity of all time do n’t make sense . From the rat that broke all of the rule , to the Thestral job that was created by theHarry Pottermovies .
Here are the20 thing About Harry Potter , Hermione Granger , And Ron Weasley That Make No Sense !
Ron’s Rule-Breaking Rat
All of the unexampled first - year students who are go to Hogwarts are contribute a lean of item that they need to buy for their time at schooling .
These item admit the uniform that they need to wear , several different book for their socio-economic class , and a list of miscellaneous detail , including a scepter , a cauldron , and a telescope .
A student who is attending Hogwarts is also able to take one of three different animals– a cat , an owl , or a toad .
The list is very clear on the fact that a scholarly person can only bring one of those three beast to Hogwarts , yet Ron was able to fetch Scabbers without it being an issue .
betrayer are n’t exactly the most popular animals in the universe , so you would call back that one of the Hogwarts staff would have had an issue with a rodent in their classroom . Snape or one of Malfoy ’s work party could also have kicked up a fuss , but no one seemed to mind .
The Parseltongue Retcon
The only reason Harry Potter was able to speak Parseltongue was due to the fact that he was one of Voldemort ’s Horcruxes .
It ’s possible ( though very hard ) to learn Parseltongue as if it were any other language , but those connected to the parentage of Salazar Slytherin own the rude power to speak with snakes .
When the part of Voldemort ’s soulfulness that was inside of Harry was destroyed inThe Deathly Hallows , it forbid Harry from being able-bodied to utter Parseltongue .
J.K. Rowling ’s words were retconned inThe Cursed Child , as Harry speaks Parseltongue while impersonating Lord Voldemort .
Harry Has His Mother’s Eyes (Until He Doesn’t)
Harry Potter is compared to his parents throughout the serial , due to the fact that he looks just like his founding father , except for his outstanding green eyes , which look just like his female parent ’s centre .
The fan once speculated about how Harry ’s eye would become relevant to the story , withHarry Potter and the Green Flame Torchbeing a rumored title for the 6th Holy Writ in the series .
The motion picture version ofHarry Potter and the Deathly Hallowsincludes a picture were Snape secern Harry that he has his mother ’s eyes , we later on see a flashback where a young Lily Evans has brown middle .
It seems that the producer were unable to find a individual gingerroot girl with blue eyes in all of Hollywood .
The Flying Ford Anglia Needs A Sat Nav
TheHarry Potterbook serial publication was filled with numerous mutual exclusiveness when it come to engagement .
TheHarry Pottermovie series was even spoilt , as the producers always seemed to forget that the serial publication was suppose to be go under in the ' 90s , yet they kept using position and property that did n’t live yet in the timeline of the story .
The journey that Harry and Ron take in the flying Ford Anglia has a notable error , as it is said that Muggles spotted them near the Post Office Tower , which had its name change in 1984 and should have been called the BT Tower .
If Harry and Ron did indeed pass the BT Tower , then they would have been locomote in theopposite directionof the Hogwarts Express .
This is because the BT Tower is about a mile southwest of King ’s Cross Station .
The Inconsistent Trace
All witches and wizards under the long time of seventeen are placed under an enchantment known as the Trace . While the Trace is in force , the Ministry of Magic will be alerted everytime magic is used around that minor crone or wizard .
The Trace seems to be suspended in field like Diagon Alley or Hogwarts , but it will set off middling much anywhere else in the Muggle humankind .
The Trace can be activated by any tour cast off in the locality of the minor wizard , as was the case with Dobby inChamber of Secrets .
The Trace is fairly discrepant from that point on , as Arthur Weasley , Albus Dumbledore , and Nymphadora Tonks all cast tour around Harry Potter when he is in Privet Drive or out on the streets , yet he never get into any trouble .
Harry Is Easily Impressed
The power to wing is something that mankind has desire since the dawning of prison term . This is something that has been reflected in pic , with characters being amazed when given the opportunity to fly .
It does n’t matter if you are being carried by Superman or riding on the back of a firedrake : it would still be awesome .
The film translation ofHarry Potterand the Prisoner of Azkabantried to use this sense of wonder during the view where Buckbeak takes Harry for a ride around Hogwarts , which is something that impresses Harry to no last .
The trouble with this storey of agitation is the fact that Harry flies all of the time .
He has been a appendage of the Gryffindor Quidditch squad for three years at this point and is commonly given the prospect to fly around on a broom , so why is he so impressed when flying on the back of a hippogriff ?
The Multiple Wand Style
The wizards in the world ofHarry Potteraren’t exactly the most well - prepare bunch in the world . You would recall that someone would have forge a carpus shoulder strap for the wand , to prevent it from being dropped or knocked from your grasp .
You would also suppose that a star would gift in a few spares to keep on their individual , as we see several incidents in theHarry Potterseries where hoi polloi are disarm and become whole incapacitated .
It ’s never explain whether wizards could use multiple wand at once in the Harry Potter books .
It does come up in the movie version ofThe Deathly Hallows , as Harry redact a spell using multiple wands in one hand during the conflict in Malfoy Manor , which seems to be more potent than the normal spells that he uses , as it blasts Lucius Malfoy across the way .
Does this mean that you could get proficient results by fighting with multiple sceptre in theHarry Pottermovie cosmos ? If so , then they do n’t more wizards use several sceptre ?
Hermione’s Birthday Should Change
The Time - Turner was one of the most polarizing items in theHarry Potterseries , as it constantly raised question about why problems could n’t be solved with time travel .
J.K. Rowling summate some new linguistic rule to the Time - Turner onPottermore , which lean some pretty terrible drawbacks . The only safe way to utilise the Time - Turner was by saving it for mundane task , which is why Hermione was throw one .
Hermione existed for a few redundant hour sidereal day , as she was using the Time - Turner to take multiple classes at once .
This mean that Hermione ’s natal day should have budge , as she was several day Old than she should have been . This also raises the question of whether her Trace would end in the first place than expected ?
The Sacrificial Power Of The Evans Bloodline
The reason Harry Potter survived the initial attempt on his biography by Lord Voldemort was due to the enchantment that was conferred to him by his female parent when she volitionally sacrifice her life for his .
This protection was so herculean that it reflected Voldemort ’s ownAvada Kedavraspell back at him and prevented him from physically bear upon Harry .
Harry Potter would later swan the same sacrificial go when he volitionally sacrifice his life while confront Lord Voldemort during the Battle of Hogwarts .
It was never let out why the sacrificial spell can only be cast by those of the Evans bloodline .
We never learn of any other instance of this happening during either of the Wizarding Wars , even though there were lot of opportunities for it to have been used .
Charlie Doesn’t Care About His Wand
Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallowsintroduced the elaborateness of wandlore to the series , which is something that had only been hinted at in previous books .
This referred to the allegiance of wand to their master , which was something that was not easily won . Those who used a baton that they had n’t deliver the goods over yet would find that their go would not be as effective .
This revelation raised all sort of questions about Ron ’s original wand , which was passed down to him by his brother Charlie . If there was such a strong connexion between the wand and the wizard , then why did Charlie give up his wand ?
If Charlie had enough money to buy a new verge , then why did n’t he allow Ron to have the newfangled wand so that he could keep his own ?
It ’s possible that Charlie ’s wand was also a hand - me - down , but from who ? Bill Weasley was his older pal , but they both attended Hogwarts at around the same time , so they must have both had wands .
