None Of The Avengers: Infinity War Setup Was Actually Paid Off

avenger : Infinity Warhas been praised for bringing together eighteen pic worth of plot of land into one epic culmination , but despite Marvel Studios ' repute for playing the long secret plan , very piffling of that setup actually paid off .

The reality is that , while Kevin Feige has a longsighted - term imagination of the MCU , it ’s one that is always in flux . How could anything else be the typeface ? Many of Marvel ’s best films have essentially been " gambles , " albeit ones that paid off . Ironically , Marvel ’s flexibility opens up major event for the studio . The shared universe modelling often involves planting the seeds of an mind well before the studio apartment design to apply it ; Wakanda , for object lesson , wasfirst teased back in 2010’sIron military personnel 2 . That sometimes means that the teases do n’t quite give off , or have to be subtly retconned to make sense . Marvel relinquish their first one - shot , The Consultant , so as to retcon Tony Stark ’s show inThe Incredible Hulk .

Related:Avengers: Infinity War Solves The MCU’s Biggest Problems

In the shell ofInfinity War , Marvel has apparently been building up to this event for the last decade ’s Charles Frederick Worth of film . TheInfinity Gauntlet first appear inThor , and there have been explicit teasers since as far back as 2012’sThe Avengers . But here ’s the gimmick ; the final film take a slightly dissimilar approach to the Mad Titan , rewrite his origins and his motivation . As a termination , as honorable asAvengers : Infinity Warmay be , it does n’t really build up on the set - up at all .

Thanos & Infinity Stones From The Avengers

It ’s important to understand that , until 2012 , Marvel never really had any plans for Thanos . In an interview withSlash Film , Marvel illusionist Kevin Feige include that post - credits scene was " Joss . Joss , Joss , and Joss . " Director Joss Whedon had always been a fan of Thanos , and his book called for some powerful cosmic being to be behind Loki ’s onslaught on Earth . Whedon approached Marvel , pitch the idea of the main villain being Thanos .

He filmed a post - credits scene that saw the Other feeler Thanos , admitting that human beings had proved more dangerous than ask . " They are unruly , " the Other noted , " and therefore can not be ruled . " That exceptional comment sure enough implied that the goal of the Chitauri invasion was a unproblematic conquest , with the Chitauri then aiming to rule the ashes of the Earth . Then , crucially , the Other continued ; " To challenge them is to court death . " That statement run Thanos to turn and face the concealment , with a smile on his face . Whedon was clearly allude to a comic - Christian Bible - accurate Thanos , one who explicitly desired to " homage expiry . "

away from that , The Avengersitself does n’t suggest that theTesseract is an Infinity Stone , either . Marvel originally foresee the Tesseract as the MCU ’s version of the Cosmic Cube , with Whedon absent - mindedly referring to it as such in interviews . Likewise , at this stage , Loki ’s Scepter is just a powerful pecker , used by the God of Mischief to control the nous of others with some possible link to the cube - not the Mind Stone .

Viewed from the perspective ofAvengers : Infinity War , The Avengersdoesn’t quite make signified . Why did Thanos give Loki one Infinity Stone so as to get another ? Why did he even send Loki in the first place , when he has theBlack Orderto do him ? It ’s unfeigned that the MCU ’s Thanos seems to like using Arabian tea ’s paws to attain his end , but he really did n’t need the God of Mischief .

Thor’s Vision From Avengers: Age of Ultron

product ofAvengers : Age of Ultronwas specially troubled , largely becauseMarvel ’s originative Committee- which ultimately disbanded in 2015 - insisted on Whedon foreshadowing future events . As a result , Scarlet Witch gives the Avengers what are clearly have in mind to be ominous vision of the futurity : Thor is distinguish he will lead Asgard to Hel ; Tony Stark is horrified to glimpse the fallen Avengers , defeated by a threat he could have done more to stop . When Thor bathe in the Water of Sight , he receives another vision that reveals the Infinity Stones are being brought into play .

So far , none of these vision have really played out as bear . It ’s dead on target the Asgardians are on the wand of extinction , but the estimate of Hel and Ragnarok has been subverted . Meanwhile , Thor ’s pursuance for the Infinity Stones - congeal up against Whedon ’s wish - was dumped byThor : Ragnarok , in favor of a completely dissimilar secret plan .

Thanos' Plan In Guardians of the Galaxy

Going back to 2014’sGuardians of the Galaxy , we saw another of Thanos ' butt - Ronan , the Kree fanatic who sought to destroy an intact major planet . This film suggested that Thanos was allied with all manner of drab force in the creation , warlords and terrorists who bring mayhem across the cosmos . He ’s minatory and impose , but there ’s no tip of hisInfinity Warphilosophy , of his desire to " rebalance the universe " by slaughtering half the living in the existence . It ’s even said that Gamora is the last of the Zehoberi backwash , highlight a retcon with herflashback scene inInfinity War .

generally , though , the movie can be register as consistent . It makes clear Thanos has become focused on acquiring the Infinity Stones , even if the intent and stratum of noesis - Gamora does n’t seem cognizant of the Stones , despite hump of the Soul Stone - is a spot off .

Gamora and Nebula in Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2

It ’s true that Thanos is barely name inGuardians of the Galaxy Vol . 2 , but the film is still a significant one in theAvengers : Infinity Warbuild - up . The dynamic between Gamora and Nebula shines a subtle light upon Thanos ’s motives , revealing just how truly evil he is , but the more crucial aspects of their human relationship - Thanos wanting to equilibrate the universe and their cognition of theSoul Stone- are absent . Here it ’s setup for small aspect while the fully grown component are ignore .

There is one crucial act of apparatus here , though : the theme that Thanos scours the galaxy and chooses minor to become his tightlipped servants and allies . Infinity Warwould sweep up that idea to explicate the BlackOrder ; in the comics , they ’re simply Thanos ’s servants and generals , but in the flick they ’re his children . That actually means both Nebula and Gamora were originally part of the Black Order , but denounce them .

alas , the item still contradict slightly . According toGuardians of the Galaxy Vol . 2 , Thanos forces his minor to compete against one another . Every time one of them loses , a body part is removed and replace with cybernetics . Gamora tended to emerge triumphant from her duels with Nebula , explain why she has few signboard of cybernetics ; Nebula , for her part , is more machine than adult female . But the respite of the Black Order show no real preindication of cybernetic division at all . It seems only Nebula and Gamora were forced to compete like this .

What Avengers: Infinity War’s Weak Payoff Means

All this is n’t to hint thatAvengers : Infinity Waris somehow a bad film - it ’s not . It ’s simply to acknowledge that Marvel Studios do actually exchange direction , a band more than most viewer actualise . Thanos is the culmination of a X ’s Charles Frederick Worth of build - up , but ironically his retconned origin and motivation sit very uncomfortably with the last ten days . This , fundamentally , an inescapable crotchet of Marvel ’s shared universe model ; sometimes the setup will go to give off .

It ’s recently been revealed that Thanos ’s backstory will be explored ina crosstie - in novelby Young Adult author Barry Lyga . Although it seems that should n’t be study canon , Lyga has solve nearly with Marvel Studios while writing the novel . Lyga forebode that the book will " change by reversal - locomotive engineer " Thanos ’s previous MCU experiences , explain how we catch up to them . It seems potential this rule book will be the best account we get as to how all the different Thanos coming into court wed together - and that will surely make it a riveting read .