Related
We almost have four picture show between us and the last batch ofStar Warsmovies , which end withRevenge of the Sithin 2005 . We ’ve had the last decade - plus to moot and analyze George Lucas ' net contributions to his distance - adventure series , which has led us to one termination : big clump of the movies just do n’t make gumption .
We ’re unforced to ignore the usual issues , like the existence of garish , fiery explosion in space . Also , nobody has been able-bodied to convince us of a plausible reason for lightsaber blades to just stop like that . We ’ll rent those slither , though . If we wanted to get that granular , we ’d never delight anything again .
However , even within the canon ofStar Warsitself and when we ignore all of the unearthly hooey that just comes with the series , the trilogy are uncanny . That ’s not needs a program line about their quality , however– plenty of people have and will continue to weigh in on that .
We ’re utter about moment that took us out of the moving-picture show , change up series continuity , or were just straight - up baffling on their own . Somehow , we care to stop here , but we could have kept going , believe us .
Here are the25 matter That Make No Sense About TheStar WarsPrequel Trilogy .
Single-ecosystem planets
This is a thing that comes up throughoutStar Wars , but the prequels make a ludicrous part to the trend .
The galaxy far , far out hosts innumerable habitable worlds . Unlike Earth , which contains jungles and deserts and snowy fleck all on the same orb , these planet just peck one biome and lodge with it . That ’s how we get “ the ice world of Hoth ” and “ the woodland moon of Endor ” in the original trilogy .
Tatooine is just one vast desert , of course . As far as we can tell , Dagobah is just swamp all over .
These do make coming into court in the prequels ( the latter in a deleted vista that shows Yoda arriving to his exile ) , but one other major planet takes this idea to straight-out silly places .
That major planet , of course , is the Republic chapiter of Coruscant , the entire surface of which is a single , enormous city . It did n’t originate in the prequels , to be fair . It originate in the 1991 legend novelHeir to the Empire . Lucas liked it so much that he incorporate it into the canon when he went back to make the other episodes .
However , considering his love of planets that are one matter and one matter only , we can see why he think that this was a ripe ADHD .
Trooper armor not stopping anything
Here ’s another affair that ’s been a problem throughout the series , but it bears reduplicate here . We ’re not sure what tempest or Clone Trooper armour is good for other than make a horde of identical enemy that it ’s alright for our heroes to destroy en masse . However , it ’s unquestionably no good against chargeman .
We suppose it ’s possible that the Trade Federation — and by and by the Rebel Alliance and Resistance — found a way to make their weapons effective against their opponents . However , if that were the case , we ’d expect the designers to update their poppycock .
The First Order has weapons that can stand up to a lightsaber , after all , and the only Jedi they know is drinking green Milk River fresh from the tap on Porg Island .
Apparently , the focus when they were design the armour was mostly on creating untold legion of sparkling , white , skeleton troop , and they did n’t get much beyond esthetic . A single shaft anywhere will be the end of whoever is wearing the hooey .
possibly the Republic and Imperial armies are so monolithic that it ’s price - prohibitory to keep update the things . However , we also know that the Empire had basically all of the money in the galaxy , so we ’re fairly sure they could open some better armour .
The duly elected queen?
We have a lot of query about Queen Amidala , and others will number up . However , while we ’re here , she do several references to her people “ elect ” her as their pansy , but that ’s kind of the antonym of how monarchies crop .
It ’s potential that she ’s a queen because her succeeding girl will be a princess , which is as good of an explanation as any and makes sense by George Lucas logic . That ’s the same idea process that pronounce that Anakin construct C-3PO and Obi - Wan does n’t recognize either him nor R2 - D2 inA New Hope .
Obviously it ’s fix a fleck fiddly to question the political social organization of fictional governments– specially in a universe in which sure members of the universe are samurai necromancer . However , words still think things , and a queen is not an elected drawing card , so why bother calling her that ?
This is far from the biggest head we have about Padmé , and we ’ll get to the others . However , they keep mentioning the whole “ elected queen ” matter throughoutThe Phantom Menace .
perhaps Lucas assume that if enough masses brought it up , the consultation would just accept it as the way of life thing are . However , it did n’t puzzle out , and it still does n’t make sensation .
What is the prophecy, anyway?
Almost the entire narrative thrust of the prequels comes down to a simple idea . Enough important Jedi believe that Anakin is a figure from one of their key vaticination that they decide to break protocol and cultivate him … and then things go horribly wrong .
vaticination are important components of many legend . The ancient Greeks used them as game equipment , and so did Shakespeare . However , the difference of opinion here is that while those other floor typically provide some specific about their subjects , the Jedi do n’t seem to have much to work with .
Even the “ opt One ” component of theHarry Potterseries make a better verbal description than the person who the Jedi remain all their hope on . The prophecy gives entropy about the subject ’s parents and his scar . It even gives his birthday .
Everyone has plenty to go on if they ’re trying to estimate out who the Wizarding World ’s Chosen One is , even if we still terminate up with a couple of choices .
In fact , we never hear the Jedi prophecy in full . All we roll in the hay is that someone will “ put down the Sith ” and “ bring balance to the Force . ”
We have a go at it ground on the events of the movies and Lucas ’ own confirmation that this means Anakin , but the Jedi are work on nothing but a blood test and hope . We assumed that they were smart than that .
Sifo-Dyas' surprise clone army
InAttack of the Clones , we learn two things about Jedi Master Sifo - Dyas . The first is that he exist and the second is that he commissioned a clone army for the Republic years before the moving-picture show started .
Obi - Wan mentions that Sifo - Dyas evaporate at some point , which means that the Kaminoans almost end up sit down on grand of clone with nobody to hail claim them .
Narratively , that army had to issue forth from somewhere and would take age for them to produce . However , that ’s where this part of the story halt making sense .
If we bewilder only to evidence within the movie , this is one of the clumsiest ways to have handled the Book of Revelation . A Jedi go to Kamino to have them build an regular army and apparently never told anyone about it .
Presumably he would have let people in on the plan once the troops were quick for delivery . However , we get it on fromGravitythat it ’s really dangerous to work in space , so he probably should have post a memoranda .
We did n’t learn anything else about this reference until theClone Warstelevision series . However , that ’s just another case of the extended cosmos picking up the movie ’ narrative slack , and without that , the character ’s existence is just confusing .
Darth Maul’s early demise
Regardless of your impression aboutThe Phantom Menace , the acrobatic affaire d’honneur between its Jedi heroes and fresh Sith learner Darth Maul are still fairly cool . If you do n’t have “ Duel of the Fates ” rattling around in your straits just thinking about those prospect , we feel sorry for you .
Maul introduced a grade of lightsaber domination that made all of the showdowns in the original trilogy seem like two old guy wire push with brooms . That ’s partially because that ’s essentially what the confrontation between Darth Vader and Obi - Wan inA New Hopewas .
Because Lucas redact soldierly art master Ray Park in the office , his stunts and strenuosity mat real , as opposed to the relentless CGI puppetry of the other two episode . It was fun , it was authentic , and it was too defective because he was only in that one moving picture .
Darth Maul could have been a majuscule villain to carry through the entire trilogy , and he was arguably the most entertaining new character of the tidy sum . keep him around would have put up some consistency and more of an electric discharge for Obi - Wan and saved fan from having to find out a crowd of eldritch new names every few years .
He finally got his due with a more elaborated plot line inThe Clone Wars , but that just reminded us of his wasted cinematic potential .
Why clone Jango Fett?
We played the video gameStar warfare : Bounty Hunter , which lets you dally as infamous soldier of fortune Jango Fett and memorise how he became the template for the Republic ’s clone army . However , again , that ’s extended - universe incentive backstory , and the actual movie does n’t extend any explanation .
All we know is that he ’s a premium hunter , the Kaminoans are using him as a transmitted cookie cutlery , and part of his payment was an unchanged copy of himself that he raise as his son . However , none of that really matters .
The Kaminoans severalize Obi - Wan that they can design clones to emphasise sealed traits and touch their developing . TheClone Warsseries even bring out that they have bit in their head to make them more docile ( and also to ensure that they ’ll follow Order 66 and eliminate the Jedi ) .
However , if they ’re changing the soldier ’ personality and acquirement that much , why did Count Dooku even necessitate to rent a guide for the clones ?
He could have saved the 20 million credit that he give to Fett and had the Kaminoans clone fundamentally anyone . Also , the technology that the producer use to control growth could seemingly create any physique they want .
Sure that would n’t have given us a needlessly complicated and lame beginning storey for Boba Fett , but sometimes you have to make sacrifice in the name of art .
Dex’s Diner
We ’re uncoerced to go for that beings in distant galaxies get hungry , and restaurants surely be . However , whereAttack of the Clonesloses us is during the part where an establishment on a far-off planet in the past just come about to have the design sensitiveness of an Earth diner from the ‘ fifty or ‘ sixty .
Yet , Dexter Jettster ’s eldritch , retro space is a thing . Maybe cool thing like the Yuuzhan Vong Invasion and almost all of the Thrawn Trilogy are n’t nigh as canonic any longer , but Dex ’s Diner sure is . So let ’s just take a moment to deal with the hard the true here .
This setting is basically just George Lucas submitting to his originative whimsey . He madeAmerican Graffiti , so he ’s in spades alright with that cosmopolitan era . However , it ’s a eldritch conjunction that took us decent out of the picture show .
Diners are ok , but we were gestate something a little more space - ish or alien than that .
The post even has theStar Warsequivalent of a waitress on roller skate , as host droid FLO has a individual roulette wheel instead of legs . The concession here could have been to place Obi - Wan ’s mystery investigation in the context of a mush tec novel , butAttack of the Clonesisn’t that self - aware .
Why did Jango Hutt bother hiring an assassin?
Obi - Wan discover the clone U. S. Army on Kamino after his sidekick Dexter Jettster tells him that the planet is the source of the mysterious saberdart that he ’d find . He found the dart sticking out of Zam Wessel , who had just tried to get rid of Amidala . The dart was in Zam Wesell because Jango Fett had tear it there .
This is all really commodious , but a lot of movie plots rely on this kind of storytelling . SoAttack of the Clonesisn’t an egregious wrongdoer here , but we ’re still inquire why Zam Wesell was there at all .
Granted , Jango Fett is a amplitude hunter and not an assassin . Maybe he has a rule about only going after outlaws , but if Dooku had just put a bounty out on Padmé , no struggle would exist .
So instead , Fett ’s program is this : spend money hire another person to do the job , but keep an oculus on them to check that they do n’t severalise the authority anything if the law mystify them . If that happen , get disembarrass of them using a weapon system that , if identified , will point to the satellite on which he is shroud .
It ’s a plan just crazy enough not to work , which it does n’t .
R2’s rockets
In our universe , technology is always changing , and raw models of power train and gadgets are perpetually coming out to replace the former single . So it ’s probably pretty weird for us to see that R2 - D2 is still in service in the original trilogy after the prequels reveal that it has been in constant habit for over two 10 .
Most multitude do n’t even keep their earpiece for longer than two years . However , then again , those thing do n’t have personality or touch on our cars .
manifestly the tech market just work differently inStar Wars , and mass keep using their thing until they explode in blank space or the Jawas get ahold of them and deal them for scrap .
However , the prequels also show that R2 has gone through some changes over the long time . Specifically , it used to have leg rockets that allow it fly for short periods of time . That come in handy when it wanted to get into a starfighter or set some bad droids on fire .
Apparently , however , these rockets were n’t handy enough for the Rebels to keep in good repair once they break , because they do n’t appear at all in the late motion-picture show .
We can intend of a few times in the original trilogy that those rockets might have help the plucky droid out , but that ’s one issue with sum thing in prequels .
