Related
George Lucas’Star WarsSequel Trilogy could have happen . Would it have been better - or more readily welcome - than Disney ’s ? When Lucas sold Lucasfilm to Disney , he already had some ideas about where theStar Warsfranchise should go . Indeed , he imagined the studio apartment producing both a Sequel Trilogy , and a serial publication of anthology films ; harmonize toThe fine art of Solo : A Star Wars Story , it was Lucas who originally came up with the idea of a Han Solo origin movie . He ’d actually spend a yr developing atreatment forStar Wars Episode VIIbefore selling to Disney .
The Sequel Trilogy was the centerpiece of Lucas ’s vision of the future , which he saw as complete the story of the Star Wars Saga . Lucas presented his ideas to Disney , but the studio apartment choose to go in a very unlike direction . Lucas does n’t seem to have been peculiarly impressed with the results , criticizingStar Wars : The Force Awakensas being far too " retro " . As he complained , " They want to do a retro pic . I do n’t like that . Every flick I work very hard to make them completely dissimilar , with different planets , with dissimilar spaceship , make it novel . " He praisedStar Wars : The Last Jedifor being " attractively made , " and was reportedly more complimentary about it . Still , even that plastic film ’s harshest critic agree that its visual esthetic is stunning , so that praise seems a shade lukewarm .
Related:Here’s What George Lucas' Star Wars Sequel Trilogy Was About
Star Wars is currently a subject of real disceptation , withThe Last Jedidividing the fanbase , andSolo : A Star Wars Storydramatically underperforming at the box office . As a result , audiences are clearly marvel just what George Lucas ’s version of the Sequel Trilogy would have looked like - and , frankly , whether it would have been a lot less controversial .
Lucas’s Sequels Would Have Given Fans The Luke They Wanted
It ’s significant to note that Luke Skywalker would n’t have been the star of Lucas ' Sequel Trilogy . One of the first details to be revealed was that Lucas ’s handling focus on on a group of stripling , most probable young Jedi who were being rail by Jedi Master Skywalker . The elder Jedi Master would have taken Yoda ’s charge to " pass on what you have watch " seriously in Lucas ’s Sequel Trilogy , and learn on a Dumbledore part in the film - the powerful and fresh lord who ’s present in the background to provide support to the stars .
Not all Luke ’s students were teenagers , though . Mark Hamill has revealed that the human relationship between Luke and Leia would have been far firm in Lucas ’s Star Wars sequels . In fact , Luke would have actually been training Leiain the ways of the Force . As Hamill noted , " I always enquire , and I do n’t read the fanfiction , why she would n’t fully explicate her Force sensibilities … It seems like a waste material of an innate endowment that she should utilize in some way . " It ’s possible we ’d have even attend the Skywalker Twins fighting side - by - side .
gratuitous to say , this approach would probably have been a lot less controversial . discrepancy over Luke ’s portrayalhas really seat at the nucleus ofStar Wars : The Last Jedi ’s critical devotee - reactions ; viewers were disgruntled with the idea of Luke as a loath , disordered figure who had even briefly considered cutting down his nephew while he lay kip . The Luke ofThe Last Jedi , so panic-stricken of the Dark Side that he take in his lightsaber on his sleeping boot , feels a little too dissimilar to the character reference who conceive even Darth Vader could be redeemed . The depiction does n’t precisely contradict - the arcs can be explained fairly easily , and every human beings has a moment of weakness - but it just was n’t what viewers of the Original Trilogy had imagined for the hereafter of Luke Skywalker .
Read More:No, Luke Skywalker Didn’t Change Personality For The Last Jedi
Lucas ' handling actually admit thedeath of Luke Skywalkeras well , but in a very different way . As Hamill observe , " I pass off to know that George did n’t drink down Luke until the end of [ Episode ] 9 , after he prepare Leia . " It fathom as though Lucas imagined a Campbellian arc for his untried champion , with the death of their wise man serving as part of their Hero ’s Journey . Given how much Campbellian archetypes inform Lucas ' original imagination forStar Wars , that should n’t really come as much of a surprise . It ’s hard to say whether or not this particular component would have proved controversial , though ; that credibly depends on how well the young heroes were agnise . Disney seem to have felt the idea was too evocative of the untested Anakin Skywalker inThe Phantom Menace , and feared it would n’t be well - receive . If the teenage ( likely ) Jedi were n’t loved by audiences , then Luke ’s dying to agnize their Hero ’s Journey would in all likelihood have actually caused something of a storm .
Lucas’s Sequels Would Also Have Gone Weirder
Lucas has always stressed that he would have avoided telling a nostalgic tale with the Star Wars Sequel Trilogy , and instead would have told a brand new story . We lately learned just how strange and strange that account would have been . Lucas described his vision like this :
" [ My sequel trilogy ] were survive to get into the microbiotic world . But there ’s this world of creatures that operate otherwise than we do . I call them the Whills . And the Whills are the one who actually control the universe . They feed off the Force . "
The Prequel Trilogy introduce the idea of midichlorians , microscopic life - forms that tie an individual to the Force . As Qui - Gon Jinn explicate it , " Without the midichlorians , life could not exist , and we would have no knowledge of the Force . They continually talk to us , telling us the will of the Force . When you learn to quiet your mind , you ’ll take heed them speaking to you . " It was one of the most controversial aspects of the prequels , with many spectator feeling this added an unnecessary layer of science - fiction to the mystical realm of the Force . It seems that Lucas intended to double - down on the musical theme , though , diving into " the microbiotic universe " . At the same clock time , notice that Lucas does n’t propose that the entire story would have centered on this concept , so it ’s important not to magnify the importance of this ; it would have been one plot of land component in an entire trilogy of films .
Related:It’s Time To Admit The Hobbit Is Worse Than The Star Wars Prequels
In Lucas ' view , not every buff would have approved of this approach . " Of naturally , a mess ofthe lover would have hat it , " he observe , " just like they did Phantom Menace and everything . " hold how unpopular the midichlorians were in the Prequel Trilogy , he ’s belike right .
Page 2 of 2:Lucas’s Vision Could Have Been Just As Divisive
Lucas' Sequels Were ‘Part of the Plan’
Lucas frankly sounds to be highly frustrated that he never got to the finish his floor . As he sound off in the same book , " All the agency back to – with the Force and the Jedi and everything – the whole construct of how things hap was laid out completely from [ the offset ] to the end . But I never go to stop . I never come to tell mass about it . "
Lucas may be overstating the case somewhat here . When it comes to the Original Trilogy , it was made up very much on the fly sheet ; he never had every planned out . Early drafts ofThe Empire Strikes Backdon’t include the thought that Darth Vader is actually Anakin Skywalker , while Luke and Leia were n’t originally imagined as siblings ( Luke ’s sis would have been enclose inEpisode VIII , a character who lived at the other side of the galaxy ) . The prequel ’s core ideas had been around since the scratch line , and the opinion of a third trilogy surely solidified in the yr ’s afterReturn of the Jedi , but it ’s not like he had a grand tale completely laid out from 1977 .
Still , that does n’t mean there was n’t a plan . Lucas had always toyed with the idea of more movies afterStar Wars Episode VIin interviews , so there is a sentience of intention to his Sequel Trilogy that will have undoubtedly buoyed fans in a way Disney ’s has n’t .
Lucas is Controversial for the Prequels - and This Would Have Been Controversial Too
It ’s almost potential to blank out that George Lucas has been every number as controversial as Kathleen Kennedy in the past tense . After all , whileThe Last Jedibacklashfeels incomparable , the Prequel Trilogy was just as derided by the Star Wars community . Fans object to the gawky storytelling , the pitiable dialogue , and characters likeJar - Jar Binks . The Mr. Plinkett reviews from Red Letter Media played a key part in this ; they were feature - length takedowns of each of the three prequels , brood their failure from filmmaking basics toStar Warslore . These reviews became see as almost definitive , and the generation of science - fiction and fancy buff who ’d grow up withStar Warsaccepted them as almost Holy Writ . That controversy has died down as a new coevals ofStar Warsviewers has become mainstream ; the genesis of young adult for whom the prequels were part of their childhood .
There ’s no understanding to imagine Lucas ’s Sequel Trilogy would have been any less controversial , especially throw that it seems to have plunk into construct from the prequels that were to a great extent criticise . give the current furor over Disney’sStar WarsSequel Trilogy , it ’s gentle to romanticize Lucas ; to ideate him as the talented filmmaker who could n’t put a base wrong . In reality , Lucas is more than capable of dividing a fanbase himself , and he in all probability would have done so . It ’s impossible to know whether theStar Warssituation would be better or worse without his involvement .
-
New fandom has a strange of properness to it , with multitude acting as though they somehow " own " the dealership they love . But in the case ofStar Wars , the films have always really been aimed at children . That means the Original Trilogy is aspire at a dissimilar generation to the Prequels , with the lifelike result of dividing the fanbase along generational lines . It ’s potential what we ’re go through with the Sequel Trilogy is the same burden , and that their response will change as the current generation ages and takes its place among the fandom . If that is the guinea pig , these three films would always have been controversial , no matter whose vision they charted .
More:When Did The Star Wars Prequels Become Cool?
